12 + 3 = 15? Looks like enough? And it even has good controls, ie no jacks. How could this problem be here? Open your opening bids. Qx = 2? If you are downgrading for that you are surely upgrading for the heart ten, the 5 card suit, and the great controls. But anyway casino/pearson points (aka rule of 15) specifically mention high card points at any links I can find. This is really a borderline hand and while I am a firm believer in the Pearson count this one has several negative features like only 5 major suit cards and really ugly spot cards. Consequently I would reluctantly pass but have no real problem if partner chose to open.