Interesting stuff, I think part of the problem is that the novice/beginner forum has nothing to do with novice or beginners. There are pretty much no beginners on the forum really. Even the ones that come and post there imo post intermediate level problems. for example, http://www.bridgebase.com/forums/topic/64852-attitude-signals/ do we think real life N/B players even know what signalling is! virtually everything in there is lower level intermediate or higher. it's like I/A has virtually no low level intermediate stuff it's all high intermediate or better. maybe the forums should be re-categorized as like level 1 level 2 and level 3 or something. I really think it might put people off joining when for example they're an intermediate and find I/A a complete mind ***** or the same with N/B looking at the N/B section and thinking what on earth is going on.