Wow, I disagree with everything said in this post. 1) I don't know how old fashioned your methods for overcalling are, but double has, for a long time, been takeout oriented, and overcalls can still be good (opening or better) hands. 2) On the issue of frequency, it is not worth it to have a direct cuebid show a very strong hand (though it used to be this way). There are so many other problem hands that arise when they open that it is unthinkable to a modern player to use this bid to show a hand that will come up maybe once in 400 deals, especially when doubling and cuebidding will be similarly effective. 3) Above all, it is false that points are more important than shape. "Simple and direct...partner immediately has a good handle on whether we should be in part-score, game or slam." This statement is also completely false, I don't know how you came to this conclusion.