HeartA

That's my thought, too.

3♦, then 3N if pd cuebid 3♠.

4♥.

I would bid 3NT, 5♣ is close.

I chose 2♣, and 2♦ is close. Pass? never!

pass.

2C for me.

Agree.

3♣.

200% to East.

1NT

5C as well.

pass of course

South is on the borderline to open (1H) or not, with 12 count, 5-3-3-2 shape and QJ doubleton. So the bidding coulg go: P-P-P-1H(North) (2D/3D?)-??? After that, it depends on individual's style to bid game (4H) or not.

clear 3C to me. will rebid H later if necessary.

Agree.

well, I take PASS as the weakest action.

3♥

yes, 2♥

Ditto. I vote for pass.

I was going to say 4♠. Well, then I read this result, then my choice looks too good to write ...

Ben, Without this problem, I would get the full score. :lol: Henri, Without your vote, I would get 0 on this. :)

if you open with 12 why not with good 11? if you open with 11 why not with (good) 10? if you open with 10 why not with (good) 9? if you open with 9 why not with (good) 8? ... ... ;):lol::P:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

I voted for 1NT. 1♠ is my second choice.