Hi, We have a tricky situation in coming up a good format to select 3 out of 6-10 pairs (IMPs) to represent our state in inter-state nationals later this year. In my view if the no of tables is less than 6 (atleast 4 scores after removing top and bottom), any form of Butler scoring is not the best. I can think of following options: a) Score boards (computer dealt) for every pair against datum prescribed by panel of experts b) Play team matches wherein each pair combines with every pair (to form a team) equally (direct or 3 way matches) c) Enlarge field by throwing it open (have more tables) and select best 3 pairs from those eligible (6-10) by Butler scores (cross-IMPs?) What would be best option from amongst the above? Any other thoughts? Rgds, RV
