scoring bug

[jimcloh]

If you go to this traveler:

http://online.bridgebase.com/myhands/hands...25698166-103032

 

Traveller 174-1125698166-103032

Nº Time North South East West Result Points Score Movie

1 2005-09-02 18:34 evora33 LTDANSHER P L A N daggg 3NxE-6 1700 14.08 Movie

2 2005-09-02 18:36 kisanth amia potam timpani 6♥xS= 1210 8.92 Movie

3 2005-09-02 18:35 faruk2 kelbonmec Soso_ch yulek 6♥S= 980 5.62 Movie

4 2005-09-02 18:34 doudoucaro patoche198 bit rossi22 6♠S= 980 5.62 Movie

5 2005-09-02 18:33 romanl mtawil xbogusik function34 6♥S= 980 5.62 Movie

6 2005-09-02 18:34 justine crmad nikola46 jhcarosell 6♥S= 980 5.62 Movie

7 2005-09-02 18:37 dirtbag hammou lena2709 gerards 5♥xS+1 750 1.08 Movie

8 2005-09-02 18:33 timnapark esclisizca napp0 dalget 4♥S+2 480 -4.38 Movie

9 2005-09-02 18:35 nadya t jag61509 pink fl sambab 5♥N+1 480 -4.38 Movie

10 2005-09-02 18:39 seven_frid nosqueeze malinka doncapone 5♥S+1 480 -4.38 Movie

11 2005-09-02 18:34 ruki bridgehear delcrest carmenxi48 4♠S+2 480 -4.38 Movie

12 2005-09-02 18:34 turkuaz10 delfius jesusjewel Cigana 4♥S+2 480 -4.38 Movie

13 2005-09-02 18:35 Mikahakfin annc8 ankiborg Mats 3♠S+3 230 -8.38 Movie

14 2005-09-02 18:43 jimcloh dixibridge marathon5 DoublinMan 4♥W+2 -680 -16.23 Movie

 

 

And look at board 14, you will see W made 4H+2, while at most of the other tables, N-S took enough tricks to make a small slam in Hs. If you open the movie for Board 14, you see that S did make 4H+2. With about 5 tricks to play, W claimed all the tricks, and while the claim was rejected and the hand played out, the credit for the contract was reversed.

 

Does this explain the increase in strange claims that I've seen, and is a "defense" to this making a correct claim prior to the end of play?

[inquiry]

And look at board 14, you will see W made 4H+2, while at most of the other tables, N-S took enough tricks to make a small slam in Hs. If you open the movie for Board 14, you see that S did make 4H+2. With about 5 tricks to play, W claimed all the tricks, and while the claim was rejected and the hand played out, the credit for the contract was reversed.

 

Does this explain the increase in strange claims that I've seen, and is a "defense" to this making a correct claim prior to the end of play?

This was a tournment, and the director "adjusted" the score. Sadly, he can't tell his left from his right, so when he adjusted, he made it EW making 4H plus two instead of NS. This was human error, not computer.