What's wrong with it?

[civill]

[hv=d=e&v=b&n=saxhxxxdkxxxxxckx&s=sq10xxhkqjxxxdcxxx]133|200|Scoring: IMP

The result is S-4♥XX-2,another room is 3♥-1.

Could you image the sequence of bidding?[/hv]

 

Clubs Match.The obvious difference is that one west opens 1♠,another opens 1♦ with responding by 1♠.What's your opinion?

[han]

many roads lead to 3H. As for 4HXX, I'm not sure I'm interested. Perhaps you can surprize me.

[civill]

I suggest that we firstly discuss on bidding,are there enough good reasons to bid 3♥,but not 4♥XX.

Later,I'll post the whole deck.Thank you in advance!

[inquiry]

[hv=d=e&v=b&n=saxhxxxdkxxxxxckx&s=sq10xxhkqjxxxdcxxx]133|200|Scoring: IMP

The result is S-4♥XX-2,another room is 3♥-1.

Could you image the sequence of bidding?[/hv]

 

Clubs Match.The obvious difference is that one west opens 1♠,another opens 1♦ with responding by 1♠.What's your opinion?

 

My bidding

 

PASS = 2H = let them decide what to do.. .

East deals and WEST gets to open? South couldn't see himself clear to bid 2♥ over EAST pass? Really, worried about that four card spade suit? How about 1♥ then if so bothered.

 

Ok, if I had to guess,

 

(P) - P* - (1S) - 2D      *yuck

(P) - 2♥ - ( P) - 2♠

(P) - 4♥ - ( X) - Pass

(P) - XX

 

The redouble here is, "I should have bid earlier, and partner cue-bid in support of hearts, surely I must be making a ton." Lesson, if you should be bidding earlier, BID EARLIER.

[civill]

I also think South should bid 2♥,but actually both rooms' south pass,One is:

S W N E

--------p

P 1D P 1S

2H 2S 3H P

4H P P X

XX P P P

 

I think East's 1♠ response has changed the sequence of bidding.Even 4♥XX may be not reasonable,but how about 4♥?Is it only an application of LOTT?

 

Another is :

S W N E

--------p

P 1S P 2C

2H 2S 3H P

P P

[civill]

It seems that ♥s are stickers.And here is the fullhand:[hv=d=e&v=b&n=saxhxxxdkxxxxxckx&w=skjxxhxxdaq10xcq10x&e=sxxxha10djxxcajxxx&s=sq10xxhkqjxxxdcxxx]399|300|Scoring: IMP

Opening lead ♥x.East gets the first trick,returns ♥10. How many tricks could you get?[/hv]

[civill]

When and where to brake?There are more cases at the Clubs tournaments:

1.

[hv=d=s&v=b&n=saxxxha987djxcaj9&w=sq98xhxxda107xcqxx&e=skjxhjxdq8xck8xxx&s=s107hkq10xxdk9xxc107]399|300|Scoring: IMP

S W N E

p p 1C p

1H p 2H p

p p

 

Open lead S8,2H+1[/hv]

 

Another room:

S W N E

p p 1C p

1H p 2S p

4H pass all

 

Open lead Sx ,4H-1.

[civill]

2.

[hv=d=e&v=e&n=s107hqxxxdj10xcqxxx&w=saqj8xxh7dq9xca97&e=s9xxh10xxda87ck108x&s=skxhakj98dkxxxcjx]399|300|Scoring: IMP

S W N E

------p

1N 2D p 2H

X 2S 3H 3S

pass all

Open lead DJ,W-3S+1;[/hv]

 

Another room:

S W N E

--------p

1H 1S 2H 2S

3D 3H p 4S

pass all

 

Same open lead,West's 4S made.

[civill]

3.

[hv=d=s&v=n&n=skq108xxxhqd1087ck10&w=s97xh9xxdk9xcaq87&e=sjhk108xdxxcjxxxxx&s=saxhaj7xxdaqjxxc9]399|300|Scoring: IMP

S W N E

1H p 4S p

6S pass all

Open lead Dx,N-6S-1[/hv]

 

Another room:

S W N E

1H p 1S p

2D p 4S pass all

 

The same open lead, North's 4S+1;

 

 

Is it the problem of brake system?