Alzheimer's Research Investigation

[thepossum]

Hi all

 

I just came across this interesting story regarding Alzheimer's research and medications, and recent investigation

 

It is made even more interesting by the connection with short-selling against questionable research

 

Would love to hear any comments, especially from assembled experts and others

 

Interesting read to us ordinary people

 

P

 

Interesting Story

 

PS I should credit Mad in America again for bringing it to my attention

[pilowsky]

If you want to keep track of articles that have been retracted - representing only the stuff that has been caught and dealt with, you can search the "Retraction Watch" database.

Here are the results for amyloid: the stuff that is seen in the brain of people that had Alzheimer's disease.

 

A simple example is the old saw that Bridge improves cognitive function and decreases the risk of dementia.

There is no evidence for this.

The 'findings' (very slender indeed) show an association between playing Bridge/Chess/wordle/ etc etc and better levels of cognitive function but there are no studies that I'm aware of that demonstrate causation.

[kenberg]

"Interesting read to us ordinary people". Yes, definitely. Thank you.

[thepossum]

"Interesting read to us ordinary people". Yes, definitely. Thank you.

:lol:

Sorry no insult intended Ken. I was talking about me :)

 

I think the thing that I am most curious about is the nature of the trading and whether the likes of the SEC have any interest in the matter

 

I am impressed at their use of public information and expertise etc

 

An impressive short indeed

[kenberg]

:lol:

Sorry no insult intended Ken. I was talking about me :)

 

I think the thing that I am most curious about is the nature of the trading and whether the likes of the SEC have any interest in the matter

 

I am impressed at their use of public information and expertise etc

 

An impressive short indeed

 

And no insult was taken. My knowledge of medicine, genetics, etc is scant. Just looking back on my own life, I believe genetic material is very significant but of course not the whole story. Choices also matter, matter a lot. and while I am sorry to hear that someone may be stacking the cards a bit for research results, I know that gets tricky to prove. By " Yes, definitely. Thank you." I meant " Yes, definitely. Thank you."

[barmar]

A simple example is the old saw that Bridge improves cognitive function and decreases the risk of dementia.

There is no evidence for this.

The 'findings' (very slender indeed) show an association between playing Bridge/Chess/wordle/ etc etc and better levels of cognitive function but there are no studies that I'm aware of that demonstrate causation.

Quite right. It's possible that the neurological traits that make you less susceptible to dementia also lead to more interest in playing mentally challenging games.

 

It's hard to perform controlled experiments to determine causal links for things like this. We can force mice to run around in mazes every day, but it's hard to make a random sample of people take up bridge. So bridge players are a self-selected group, and selection bias taints the results.

[kenberg]

Some of these "improvements" are amusing. I work crossword puzzles more often than I used to. Becky is much much faster at it than I am but I am starting to catch on to some of it. I work the daily puzzle in WaPo which is reprinted from the LA Times. I have learned that if the clue involves a cookie and the answer is to be four letters long then the answer is oreo. Similarly, a four letter answer to a clue that involves music is aria, and a four letter answer to a clue that involves colleges is yale. Yoko Ono makes frequent appearances in these puzzles. Also the musical group ELO. If I worked puzzles from a different source, I suppose I would need to learn a different set of frequently appearing answers.

 

I don't so much expect such activities to ward off dementia, it's more that I see it as reassurance that I have not yet completely lost it. On the physical side, I mow grass with a push mower. Sure, the blades spin by means of electricity, but I push it, I don't ride on it. My cardiologist has scheduled me for a stress test that I expect to do fine on, the reason being that I have no problems mowing the grass. Well, too hot lately but that will change, I hope.

 

So. I play bridge because I enjoy it, just as I mow my grass because I enjoy it. If I can no longer do one or the other, I will figure I have a problem. Warding off problems is partly genes, partly choices, partly luck.

 

Anyway, the thread is Alzheimer's and I am sorry to hear that some of the data might be fudged.

[pilowsky]

So. I play bridge because I enjoy it, just as I mow my grass because I enjoy it. If I can no longer do one or the other, I will figure I have a problem. Warding off problems is partly genes, partly choices, partly luck.

 

 

Maybe it's the element of danger that causes the enjoyment.

I am married to a 63-year-old accountant who subscribes to the Harvard Men's Health Watch. My husband had a small heart attack last winter. He feels fine now, but he has to take five pills a day. He's back to his golf, and when he doesn't play he walks two miles a day. But he insists on mowing the lawn himself, pushing a heavy mower, and I'm worried. What do you think?

[kenberg]

Maybe it's the element of danger that causes the enjoyment.

 

 

 

 

Simon HB Harvard Mens Health Watch. 1999 Jun;3(11):8. said:

 

I am married to a 63-year-old accountant who subscribes to the Harvard Men's Health Watch. My husband had a small heart attack last winter. He feels fine now, but he has to take five pills a day. He's back to his golf, and when he doesn't play he walks two miles a day. But he insists on mowing the lawn himself, pushing a heavy mower, and I'm worried. What do you think?

 

 

 

It's a legitimate question but what are the alternatives? You would have to know the individuals and even then it's a bit tough. I got most of the crazy out of my system when I was in my teens. Now, in my 80s, I take life very seriously. Somewhere along the way I came to realize that I want to live because there are several people who very much hope I will do so. Crazy is not the way to do it, but sitting around doing nothing is not such a good idea either. When I was 13 and going off to summer camp my doctor refused to sign off on some planned activities because I had a heart murmur. I ignored his restrictions and probably became healthier by doing so. That's not where I am now, but I am not sitting still either. Becky and I have good conversations regarding what is sensible and what is not. And we do pay attention to doctors. And then we make our own decisions.

 

We all make such choices, they just come up more often when you are 80 than they do when you are 40. 63 is between 40 and 80.

[pilowsky]

I'm with you Ken. It was hard to be certain which problem exercised Simon HB's correspondent the most.

Possibly she was most concerned about being married to a 63 year old accountant.

[pilowsky]

Yesterday a news item appeared in which it was asserted that picking your nose may cause Alzheimer's disease.

Here's the paper.

It turns out that Chlamydia pneumoniae (no, not that chlamydia) is the culprit if you're a mouse:

In vitro, C. pneumoniae was able to infect peripheral nerve and CNS glia. In summary, the nerves extending between the nasal cavity and the brain constitute invasion paths by which C. pneumoniae can rapidly invade the CNS likely by surviving in glia and leading to Aβ deposition.

[jillybean]

My partner was diagnosed with "Alzheimer's" a few years ago. I threw myself into learning all about the disease to cope with the diagnosis and best prepare for his future.

After much research, discussions with a open minded doctor, brain scans, and cognitive tests I started questioning the diagnosis, and I still am. IMO "Alzheimer's" appears to be used as a catch all for aged related memory loss and other symptoms.

Past head trauma, sleep apnea, and other factors I won't share, seem to be contributing factors in his case. The sleep apnea piece has been a huge factor and in my non medically qualified opinion, has seen a significant improvement once treated. Over these past few years I had contact with other alzheimer's suffers and our case is definitely atypical.

 

This is an interesting article , "alzheimer's is not a brain disease"

https://www.sciencealert.com/alzheimers-might-not-actually-be-a-brain-disease-expert-says

[Winstonm]

My partner was diagnosed with "Alzheimer's" a few years ago. I threw myself into learning all about the disease to cope with the diagnosis and best prepare for his future.

After much research, discussions with a open minded doctor, brain scans, and cognitive tests I started questioning the diagnosis, and I still am. IMO "Alzheimer's" appears to be used as a catch all for aged related memory loss and other symptoms.

Past head trauma, sleep apnea, and other factors I won't share, seem to be contributing factors in his case. The sleep apnea piece has been a huge factor and in my non medically qualified opinion, has seen a significant improvement once treated. Over these past few years I had contact with other alzheimer's suffers and our case is definitely atypical.

 

This is an interesting article , "alzheimer's is not a brain disease"

https://www.sciencea...ase-expert-says

 

My sister-in-law told me recently what her doctor told her and it made a lot of sense. She said if you forget where you put the car keys that is because you weren't paying attention-if you've forgotten what car keys are for, then you have a problem.

 

PS. As an retired RN, my understanding 10 years ago was that Alzheimer's could only be truly diagnosed in an autopsy. I do not know if that has changed. I bring it up only to suggest that if still true, doubting the diagnosis is reasonable.

[jillybean]

My sister-in-law told me recently what her doctor told her and it made a lot of sense. She said if you forget where you put the car keys that is because you weren't paying attention-if you've forgotten what car keys are for, then you have a problem.

 

PS. As an retired RN, my understanding 10 years ago was that Alzheimer's could only be truly diagnosed in an autopsy. I do not know if that has changed. I bring it up only to suggest that if still true, doubting the diagnosis is reasonable.

 

I am not medically trained in any way but it is my understanding that the rate of brain atrophy is significantly accelerated in those suffering from dementia/alzheimers. Although significant atrophy does not occur until the final stages I would have thought brain scans could detect an increased rate from earlier on.

The absence of stroke, traumatic head injury or other hereditary diseases must lead towards a diagnosis of dementia, alzheimer's being the most common form.

[pilowsky]

There are many diseases (and drugs) that can reduce cognitive ability.

As we age, some of these can happen at the same time making a "straightforward" diagnosis very difficult.

To make things even more difficult no two people experience the same disease process the same way.

It is also possible for one person to experience more than one degenerative problem at the same time - or sequentially.

 

This problem is made even more frustrating with disorders that affect the mind because it is very hard to objectively assess "thinking" unless major deficits are present.

There are no simple X-rays (although imaging techniques are making a lot of progress in helping to understand brain function) to say how badly affected a person's mind is.

"Brain atrophy" on an MRI/CT or plain X-ray doesn't say much about brain function, and is common as people age.

[Winstonm]

I am not medically trained in any way but it is my understanding that the rate of brain atrophy is significantly accelerated in those suffering from dementia/alzheimers. Although significant atrophy does not occur until the final stages I would have thought brain scans could detect an increased rate from earlier on.

The absence of stroke, traumatic head injury or other hereditary diseases must lead towards a diagnosis of dementia, alzheimer's being the most common form.

pilowsky is the expert but my understanding is that Alzheimer’s is not about atrophy but about plaques that interrupt the neurons’ abilities to communicate. Those plaques are not detectable by scans or xray.

[kenberg]

This discussion is interesting and quite possibly useful. My approach to many medical issues is much like I understand JB's to be. Doctors are useful, very useful, but they are not gods, they are not infallible, so doing some personal ope minded research is important. It was maybe 12 years ago I was diagnosed with sleep apnea. I believe this diagnosis saved my life. I had been having some memory issues, then I had a TIA (aka a mini-stroke), a doctor suggested I be tested for sleep apnia. There is something called the alnea-hypopnia index. Below 5 is normal,5-30 indicates problems, above 30 is a serious problem, mine was above 60. Now, using a BiPap, my AHI last night was 2.85.

 

As to brain decay: This same doctor, Dr Chu by name, had done some sort of scan and asked me to come in to see the results, which she did before reading them herself. About the first thing she said when the results appeared on the screen was "Oh, your brain has shrunk". People probably vary in how they take such comment. I saw it as showing that this was a doctor would tell me the truth in a straightforward way. I very much like that.

 

As to Alzheimer's and whether a diagnosis is accurate. It gets tricky. A friend's wife died of Alzheimer's and she went through what I gather were pretty predictable stages and so the diagnosis was probably correct. I have some concerns about myself. I am adopted and my knowledge of my birth parents is meager, but my understanding is that my birth mother did die of Alzhweimer's. Otoh, she died in her 90s and someone who is 90 is likely to have issues, maybe quite a few issues, and likely to die of one or the other of them, or of a combination.

 

JB describes her partner's doctor as open-minded. That's the sort I want. Some forty-plus years ago I had an auto-immune eye disease that requiredsome substantial drugs. Before taking the treatment I had to be cleared by my general practitioner except he was in the hospital himself, so I went to the doc who was covering for him When I explained my disease to her she replied "I never heard of that one, I will have to look it up" OMG, a doctor who easily admits to not knowing everything. Again reactions to such a statement probably vary but for me it created trust. Of course she doesn't know everything. I am a Ph.D. mathematician. That doesn't mean that I can explain the proof of Fermat's Last Theorem if we meet on the street. I could understand it if I took a month or so to study it.

 

As I said, an interesting and very possibly useful discussion.

[Winstonm]

Let me reiterate I am not a doctor. My experience is much like yours-physicians are highly educated professionals but like us all are fallible-except for the cardiologists-just ask them, they’ll tell you I am right.😊

[sharon j]

This topic is of great interest to me. I have noticed a difference in my husband's mental acuity in the last 6 + months. I've told him that I'm concerned about this and have asked him to discuss it with his doctor. Outside of doing this, I have no idea what I should do or even if there is anything I can do.

[Winstonm]

There are medicines but my experience (more than 10 years ago) is they were not very effective.

[jillybean]

pilowsky is the expert but my understanding is that Alzheimer’s is not about atrophy but about plaques that interrupt the neurons’ abilities to communicate. Those plaques are not detectable by scans or xray.

 

Agree, the atrophy is very late stage. I believe that the plaques are cleaned out during deep non REM sleep, something which Sleep Apnea Sufferers are severely lacking in.

 

This topic is of great interest to me. I have noticed a difference in my husband's mental acuity in the last 6 + months. I've told him that I'm concerned about this and have asked him to discuss it with his doctor. Outside of doing this, I have no idea what I should do or even if there is anything I can do.

Does your husband snore, have breathing difficulties or interrupted sleep - see a sleep specialist.

The Alzheimer's Association offers a wealth of support and information.

[sharon j]

He doesn't snore. His sleep patterns have changed, however. He naps multiple times a day. He says he sleeps fine at night. I'm only aware of him being awake when he gets up to use the bathroom once or so at night.

 

I will see what help I can get from the Alzheimer's research Investigation.

 

I appreciate your suggestion.

[kenberg]

This topic is of great interest to me. I have noticed a difference in my husband's mental acuity in the last 6 + months. I've told him that I'm concerned about this and have asked him to discuss it with his doctor. Outside of doing this, I have no idea what I should do or even if there is anything I can do.

 

Guys can be resistant.

 

In my case, my wife Becky had mentioned several times that there were times at night when I seemed to have gaps in my breathing. No snoring, but breathing gaps. I pooh-poohed this. My mistake. Becky also commented o my memory lapses. It took a TIA to get my attention. And then an attentive doctor.

 

I am not saying he has apnea, but I had apnea. I am not saying he has Alzheimer's but my friend's wife had Alzheimer's. I am saying that not getting medical attention earlier was an extremely serious mistake of mine, but I corrected it in time.

 

You could show him this post. Guys often do not listen to their wives. Well, guys often do not listen to anyone. But I have been there. I have come to realize that there are people, Becky but not only Becky, who would like me to stick around for a while. Sound familiar? Good luck with this.

 

Ken

[sharon j]

Thank you, Ken. I will have to make an effort to listen to his breathing at night. LOL That won't be easy for me. I'm usually dead to the world when my head hits the pillow.

 

I guess I could maybe fib about it and see if he will see his doctor about it. He needs to stay around longer than me for sure.

 

Thanks again.

[kenberg]

Thank you, Ken. I will have to make an effort to listen to his breathing at night. LOL That won't be easy for me. I'm usually dead to the world when my head hits the pillow.

 

I guess I could maybe fib about it and see if he will see his doctor about it. He needs to stay around longer than me for sure.

 

Thanks again.

 

Maybe this? As a present to you (Christmas, birthday, or just a present) he gets checked out by a doc. Maybe you are wrong, maybe you have misread the situation, but whether right or wrong you are worried, and simply as a gift to you he could get checked out. It sounds as if you could not imagine a finer gift.

 

Although my first seventy years were not totally free of medical issues, they very largely were and so I just found it really tough to believe that I had anything seriously wrong with me. Now I will be 84 in January and it is much easier to think "Hey, maybe I need to get this whatever it is checked out". I don't plan on dying tomorrow or next week or next year, but I am much more aware of life having an endpoint. It's a transition in thinking. My older daughter was here for a visit the other day and she was authentically pleased by my optimistic outlook. But realism also comes into play. I can be thankful for the past, enjoy the present, be optimistic about the future, and still realize that I should not be making any twenty-year plans.

 

Again, good luck. It's just a fact of online conversations that we do not really know each other, but I wish you and your husband the best.