A moose over a multi

[manudude03]

From my previous thread:

 

Incidentally, that looks like a very entertaining session with several interesting hands. Perhaps you might consider posting, inter alia, Hand 7 from the other table (after Multi-2♦ opening) as well?

 

As requested...

 

[hv=pc=n&w=shakqt9732dkt9cak&d=s&v=b&b=7&a=2d(multi%2C%20weak%202%20in%20major%20or%204441%20strong)]133|200[/hv]

 

IMPs scoring, all vul. Assume double is a big hand or a weak NT with all other overcalls being natural (and jumps are strong), what do you do here?

[LBengtsson]

It's a big hand. A very big hand. lol! So X

[nige1]

[hv=pc=n&w=shakqt9732dkt9cak&d=s&v=b&b=7&a=2d(multi%2C%20weak%202%20in%20major%20or%204441%20strong)]133|200|ManUDude03 'IMPs scoring, all vul. Assume double is a big hand or a weak NT with all other overcalls being natural (and jumps are strong), what do you do here?'

++++++++++++++++++++

I rank...

1. Double = T/O Postpone the problem.

2. 6♥ = Landy slam try.

[/hv]

[LBengtsson]

[hv=pc=n&w=shakqt9732dkt9cak&d=s&v=b&b=7&a=2d(multi%2C%20weak%202%20in%20major%20or%204441%20strong)]133|200|ManUDude03 'IMPs scoring, all vul. Assume double is a big hand or a weak NT with all other overcalls being natural (and jumps are strong), what do you do here?'

++++++++++++++++++++

I rank...

1. Double = T/O Postpone the problem.

2. 6♥ = Landy slam try.

[/hv]

 

what is 'Landy slam try' nige1? guess at final contract and hope to make? I have never heard of this...

[smerriman]

what is 'Landy slam try' nige1? guess at final contract and hope to make? I have never heard of this...

Sandra Landy (no relation to Alvin) was known for the 'Landy game try' - bid game, and try to make it.

[akwoo]

I think I prefer 6♥ to X here. The problem with X is that you're very unlikely to have some intelligent auction to figure out if 6♥ is on. Even if it doesn't come back to you at 4♠, it might come back to partner at 5♠ the second time around. If you're going to have to guess anyway, you might as well guess in a way that also forces the opponents to guess whether to bid 6♠ or not.

[jillybean]

[sTOP CARD] 6♥

[Cyberyeti]

Sandra Landy (no relation to Alvin) was known for the 'Landy game try' - bid game, and try to make it.

 

There is a local player who has this sort of game try named after him, you also have the equivalent game invite, where you bid game and invite partner to make it.

[P_Marlowe]

Hi,

 

X, followed by 5H.

 

They may sac in 6S, but I have no idea, if 6H makes, so I may get more than game.

 

With kind regards

Marlowe

[Cyberyeti]

I think I prefer 6♥ to X here. The problem with X is that you're very unlikely to have some intelligent auction to figure out if 6♥ is on. Even if it doesn't come back to you at 4♠, it might come back to partner at 5♠ the second time around. If you're going to have to guess anyway, you might as well guess in a way that also forces the opponents to guess whether to bid 6♠ or not.

 

It won't come back to you at 4♠, this is a multi, massive odds LHO passes or bids 2♥ if you double thinking his partner has hearts, then opener will bid 2♠ if partner doesn't get in the way. Any bounce will take place between you and partner next time.

[pescetom]

5♠ = Exclusion Blackwood, in this auction?

If so it would do the trick.

 

Just curious, I realise OP specified all natural.

[akwoo]

It won't come back to you at 4♠, this is a multi, massive odds LHO passes or bids 2♥ if you double thinking his partner has hearts, then opener will bid 2♠ if partner doesn't get in the way. Any bounce will take place between you and partner next time.

 

I've never played Multi, but shouldn't one of P or XX show spades by responder? Or 2H can show spades and one of P and XX can show neither? The X gives responder a free option; the system should allow them to take advantage of it.

[Cyberyeti]

I've never played Multi, but shouldn't one of P or XX show spades by responder? Or 2H can show spades and one of P and XX can show neither? The X gives responder a free option; the system should allow them to take advantage of it.

 

P suggests playing in diamonds (particularly if the weak 2 can be 5 cards), XX suggests a whale with some diamonds and taking some money out of something, or did when I played a multi, 2♥ is any other hand that wouldn't raise hearts and 2♠ is a heart raise.

[Gilithin]

I've never played Multi, but shouldn't one of P or XX show spades by responder?

Typically Pass offers ♦ as a suit to play in and either i) XX asks Opener to bid their suit and bids are natural; or ii) the X is ignored with 2♥ being P/C and XX showing an unknown suit to play in. Maybe you could expand on your idea to produce something better?

[gszes]

3h (assuming strong means at least 1 round force). This will give me the scientific edge of 5s as exclusion. If 3h is not forcing then I will opt for x and hope we can sort things out later.