Seemingly simple but we disagreed

[Wackojack]

This looks like a very simple situation, yet my partner and I disagreed about the correct response. We agreed to play unassuming cue bids. Don't forget this is match points [hv=d=w&v=n&s=s843h743d7ckq7642]133|100|Scoring: MP[/hv]

[Walddk]

I promise not to forget that it's MP if you promise to tell me what he opened :P

 

Roland

[MickyB]

I think 2♥ is clearcut here (if the auction is what I think it is!)

[Gerben42]

If it's 1♦ 1♥ Pass I surely bid 2♥ here.

[Walddk]

After that really is the auction, 2♥ is what this hand is worth. It's far away from being a sound raise (2♦).

 

Roland

[P_Marlowe]

Hi,

 

2H, if the auction is, as Gerben suggested.

 

This hand is not worth a cue raise, the only

question is, if you should bid 2C instead of 2H,

assuming 2C is not forcing merely constructive.

 

With kind regards

Marlowe

[Guest Jlall]

2H for me as well at the speculated auction. I would need another queen or so to cuebid.

[Fluffy]

That auction wuldn't happen because I would open 3♣, and since it is west the dealer director would penalize my partner not to bid on first round.

[luis]

I think "other" is clear with this hand.

The sequence

1? - 1??

1?? - 1other

shows a weak hand with 6 clubs and two top honors. Singleton in diamonds. Pd can now place the contract or relay bidding 2something. Over 2something I'd bid 3?! showing interest in what's happening.

[Blofeld]

I like Luis' approach, and think it will work on most hands, but I can see disaster if LHO weighs in with 2thingies, and partner, holding exactly the right hand for the rarely seen Fairport Convention, will jump-cue 4thingies (showing six diamonds headed by the queen, 9 points precisely, and a club shortage (if a singleton, it must be an EVEN card)). Now you're rather too high on a misfit hand.

 

But I suppose that it is Matchpoints.

[scoob]

http://www.speedofwood.com/forumcrap/roofletrain.gif

[Wackojack]

I have just come back from holidaying in France and when look at bridgebase I see that you have correctly guessed my question (that I forgot to put) and also provided the answer. Thanks for that, I am really impressed.

[Fluffy]

I still dunno what thios proiblem is about.

[inquiry]

I still dunno what thios proiblem is about.

It was a mental excerise to see if you could read the mind of the poster.. .the one clue is this (in bold) from the original post....

This looks like a very simple situation, yet my partner and I disagreed about the correct response. We agreed to play unassuming cue bids.   Don't forget this is match points

 

Since unassuming cue-bid was mentioned, the opponent must have bid something, and partner must have made an overcall and the next hand passed.

 

This means, in all likelyhood, West opened a red suit, and partner overcalled in a major at the one level. So the question is do you raise partners major to the two level, or cue-bid to show a little something. The people who choose to guess, chose an opoening bid of 1♦ and a 1♥ overcall (surely 1♥ instead of 1 spade because of the options in the poll, and surely 1♦. else 2♦ here really makes no sense).

 

Ben

[PriorKnowledge]

I think figuring out the original question from the clues is more interesting and fun then providing the answer!

[Fluffy]

I was a bit puzzled because I dunnowhat unasuming cuebids is, I though it was something you do bidding controls at teh 4 level :D.