rebid six-card minor or support partner's major

[ChrisIrv]

Playing matchpoints, we hold J52 982 K AKJ843 and open one Club. Partner responds one Spade. Should we rebid our six-card Club suit, or should we supports partner's Spades with Jack third?

Would there be a different response playing imps?

Many thanks.

[eagles123]

I would bid 2 spades

[Cyberyeti]

System matters here:

 

Do you bid spades in front of diamonds with 4 of each ?

Would a 2♠ jump shift have been weak or strong ?

[ChrisIrv]

Many thanks for the comments so far. We are playing 4-card majors with a weak No Trump. A jump to 2S would be weak.

Responder's hand was K843 AK7 J98 965.

[Cyberyeti]

Many thanks for the comments so far. We are playing 4-card majors with a weak No Trump. A jump to 2S would be weak.

Responder's hand was K843 AK7 J98 965.

 

Our auction would be either:

 

1♣-1♠-2♣-2♦(art inv+)-2♠-2N-3♣/3N

1♣-1♠-2♠-2N-3♣/3N

 

In either case for us responder shows a 4333 11 ish, opener can choose whether to punt 3N.

 

I'm not sure which is best initially, if 2♠ would have been strong I think the WJS hands make 2♠ best, it's closer if you play 2♠ weak.

[helene_t]

Many thanks for the comments so far. We are playing 4-card majors with a weak No Trump. A jump to 2S would be weak.

Responder's hand was K843 AK7 J98 965.

When you play weak notrump, raising partner's spades can't be based on a balanced minimum. So you show extras, or some distributional values. This makes it problematic to raise on 3-card support with a minimum.

 

I would rebid 2♣. You may get the chance to show the spades support later, while if you start with 2♠, I am not sure if you will be able to show that you have six clubs.

[P_Marlowe]

Hi,

 

#1 Do you regular raise with 3 Card support Partner 4 Card suit?

Do you have Methods to detect, that you only have a 7 Card suit fit?

Do you by pass Diamonds, when Holding 4 Diamonds and a 4 Card Major, if you do,

the probability, that the spade suit is a 5 carder goes down, hence raising looses

some of ist Appeal.

Similar, if the opener was in 2nd seat, the Need to raise spades goes down.

 

#2 Given that 66% of all your HCPs are in your suit, I would rebid my suit.

#3 Playing MP, there is a adv. playing the Major, …, if you go plus, playing IMPs,

going plus is more important, if you have a spade fit and game, Partner will be

able to ask for secondary support.

 

Finnally, given that you are dead min, I would try to go slower, raising Partners Major

is a life Signal, and Partner may get excited, move the single king to another suit,

raising spades has a lot going for it.

 

With Kind regards

Marlowe

[FelicityR]

Raising a major to the two level on a three card suit in Acol is really only an option where you don't have any better alternative bid available. To supress a 'jolly' good six card ♣ suit headed by AKJ would be anti-bidding to me.

 

If partner has extras, you can show ♠ support on the next round.