A very instructive hand

[whereagles]

[hv=d=w&v=b&n=skj8xxhajxd9xxxcx&w=s9xxht9xdakqtcaxx&e=sqtxhqxxdjxckqtxx&s=saxhkxxxdxxxcjxxx]399|300|Scoring: MP

West North East South

..1♦...pass..1NT..pass

pass....2♠.....X (end)[/hv]

Here is a hand from a national tournament that comes to show that it is better to take immediate action at low level rather than waiting and make a later "safe" bid, after opps have limited themselves.

 

North decided to pass 1st round because of the broken spade suit and having only 9 hcp. Later on, he felt 2♠ was a safe balancing bid: 5 cards, lenght in diams, overcall on a suit both opps bypassed. In fact, the situation was perfect to balance with 2♠. You can't have a much better hand to bid here, so what could go wrong?

 

Well, as you can see, a lot could go wrong. East doubled to show a max 1NT response and there the matter rested. After the inevitable 1 down, South pointed out to North that an immediate 1♠ overcall would give take the hand off his chest and put partner in the picture. It would go..

 

West North East South

..1♦....1♠....1NT..(end)

 

and North could now pass 1NT without a qualm.

[luke warm]

he could also pass 1nt without a qualm on the actual bidding, eh?

[flytoox]

he could also pass 1nt without a qualm on the actual bidding, eh?

No, he might miss a good part score. I agree passing 1D then bidding 2S is wrong though.

[pigpenz]

better to bid to start with in my opinion, once you pass both opponetns are better informed than you are.