Sanity check on reopening

[apollo1201]

IMPs, all red, you deal and pass the following collection (system kindof SAYC+ with 12HCP opening)

 

AJ9x

K9xx

JTx

Qx

 

LHO preempts 3C, passed back to you.

 

pass 3C pass pass

?

 

I'm asking for a sanity check and will explain why later.

 

So pass or X ? Yeah, I know Qx C are not the best assets of the hands...so I didn't ask what you think of 3NT bid :D

[LBengtsson]

pass. pass. pass. pass. pass...

[nige1]

[hv=pc=n&s=saj93hk975djt7cq3&d=s&v=b&b=7&a=p3C(PRE)pp?]133|200|

imps. SAYC with 12 HCP openings.

I rank

1. Double = T/O. Partner won't expect more.

2. Pass = NAT. Seemingly safe but not without risk.

3. 3N = NAT? Foolhardy and might be misinterpretated.

[/hv]

[FelicityR]

One rule I was taught by my late bridge teacher - a Life Master - many years ago is never try to balance at the three level with a balanced hand (4333 4432) even if your hand is near an opening bid. This was said in reference to a weak two opening raised to the three level pre-emptively. Given that you are vulnerable and the opponents are too, and it is a second hand pre-empt, and that some opponents will not make a barrage raise to four clubs with a desired hand, it's an easy pass for me.

[PhilG007]

Anyone who bids on this tawdry collection is either lion hearted

or should be referred to a good psychiatrist. My conscience is clear...I PASS

There are occasions when protecting partners pass are not applicable...this is

definitely one of them...

[PhilG007]

[hv=pc=n&s=saj93hk975djt7cq3&d=s&v=b&b=7&a=p3C(PRE)pp?]133|200|

imps. SAYC with 12 HCP openings.

I rank

1. Double = T/O. Partner won't expect more.

2. Pass = NAT. Seemingly safe but not without risk.

3. 3N = NAT? Foolhardy and might be misinterpretated.

[/hv]

Errrr... correct me if I'm wrong but I can only see 11 hcp in that hand(?)

[MrAce]

This is a borderline decision. I would have opened previous round.

I personally would always double at MP but at IMPs it is a bit more risky.

Just because we are coming from pass and pd won't expect more does not change the possibility that 3 level can be already too high for us.

Overall I would DBL but it is not clear cut and pass is reasonable as well.

[gordontd]

Errrr... correct me if I'm wrong but I can only see 11 hcp in that hand(?)

Well what do you expect- it’s a passed hand!

[MrAce]

Well what do you expect- it's a passed hand!

 

http://www.bridgebase.com/forums/public/style_emoticons/default/smile.gif

[apollo1201]

Thanks for your comments, as you had guessed I had Xed (thinking my initial pass made it clear I didn't have a powerhouse).

 

My inexperienced partner had paid due respect to the stop sign, but she never plays in tempo as she needs more time to think. RHO had raised concerns about my reopening after partner's "hesitation". Especially after I tabled dummy. I really thought, though, it was a bit aggressive but quite ok (I tend to reopen easily). Facing a real hestitation from a more experienced partner, I'd have passed as I knew the X was not cut clear.

 

Partner had something close to Kx(x) ATxxx Kx(x) Axx and passed initially (I think it is quite clear to pass), but now jumped to 4H and wrapped up 11 tricks after guessing everything right incl. picking up the trumps that split J - Qxx.

 

Other table +200 when teammates commited the same preempt red 2nd hand with KJ 7th and 2 queens.

 

No TD called finally when opps learnt about my partner's status and her funny comment "your take-out double is weak".

 

But I still wanted to check...

 

Nice year-end to all!

[PhilG007]

Well what do you expect- it’s a passed hand!

Read Nige's post....Where is the phantom 1 point that he sees

but others don't(?!)

[Joe_Old]

I know that I'm adding this after a spoiler, but this is a routine (but very borderline) double. It's also a double if you are in fourth seat and LHO dealt and bid 3♣. In every expert partnership I know, protecting partner when you're in the balancing seat is a must, and two four card majors makes this even more necessary.

 

Granted, there are wasted values in the minors, and if the hand was xxxx xxxx AQx KQ, I'd pass.

[PhilG007]

Thanks for your comments, as you had guessed I had Xed (thinking my initial pass made it clear I didn't have a powerhouse).

 

My inexperienced partner had paid due respect to the stop sign, but she never plays in tempo as she needs more time to think. RHO had raised concerns about my reopening after partner's "hesitation". Especially after I tabled dummy. I really thought, though, it was a bit aggressive but quite ok (I tend to reopen easily). Facing a real hestitation from a more experienced partner, I'd have passed as I knew the X was not cut clear.

 

Partner had something close to Kx(x) ATxxx Kx(x) Axx and passed initially (I think it is quite clear to pass), but now jumped to 4H and wrapped up 11 tricks after guessing everything right incl. picking up the trumps that split J - Qxx.

 

Other table +200 when teammates commited the same preempt red 2nd hand with KJ 7th and 2 queens.

 

No TD called finally when opps learnt about my partner's status and her funny comment "your take-out double is weak".

 

But I still wanted to check...

 

Nice year-end to all!

You were very fortunate.. you got away with it ...THIS time(!)

[apollo1201]

You were very fortunate.. you got away with it ...THIS time(!)

 

Begginer's luck😊

[PhilG007]

I know that I'm adding this after a spoiler, but this is a routine (but very borderline) double. It's also a double if you are in fourth seat and LHO dealt and bid 3♣. In every expert partnership I know, protecting partner when you're in the balancing seat is a must, and two four card majors makes this even more necessary.

 

Granted, there are wasted values in the minors, and if the hand was xxxx xxxx AQx KQ, I'd pass.

"Granted there are wasted values in the minors"

Exactly the reason why you should pass. Of course,fortune is allied to the brave..

but fortune can be fickle....

[Jinksy]

Read Nige's post....Where is the phantom 1 point that he sees

but others don't(?!)

 

Nigel is describing the system, not the hand.

[Joe_Old]

"Granted there are wasted values in the minors"

Exactly the reason why you should pass. Of course,fortune is allied to the brave..

but fortune can be fickle....

 

I guess that you don't understand the form of scoring. Red, IMPs, you stretch to reach game. Passing is understandable, but it's not winning bridge.

[Tramticket]

This is finely balanced and state of the match might affect the decision. There is a big risk of missing a vulnerable game (or a nice penalty) if we pass. On the other hand, there is a risk of conceding 1,100 or more when RHO has a big hand and a misfit with his partner.

 

I would probably double - nervously!

 

At match points, it's an easy double.

[apollo1201]

I would probably double - nervously!

 

Let me reassure you, I was also nervous😰... especially with an inexperienced partner. Her jump to 4H almost finished me and I breathed some relief when it wasn't Xed.

 

But after seeing her masterizing the play for 11 tricks😱

[GrahamJson]

Hmmm, perhaps I’m being a bit simplistic, but if a 4432 Hand isn’t worth bidding at the one level I don’t see how it is worth bidding at the three level.

 

Look at it another way. If you pass and it turns out you could have made game I dont think team mates will give you a hard time. If you double and go for 1100 on a part score hand things might be a bit different.

[kfitz]

This seems absolutely clear to me , you are max for your initial pass and there are so many hands pd would have to pass which you must now protect, every hand with only one major and no 6+ suit in fact

[kfitz]

If you won’t reopen in spots like this you force pd to put their vuln neck on the chopping block with all kinds of hands that will prove disastrous when rho proves to have many of the high cards you have here

[Winstonm]

The major reason to pass this hand is that at imps there isn't enough difference between +100 and +140 to argue over and the chances you have missed game are virtually zero while the risk of -500 or -800 is very real.

[MrAce]

The major reason to pass this hand is that at imps there isn't enough difference between +100 and +140 to argue over and the chances you have missed game are virtually zero while the risk of -500 or -800 is very real.

 

http://www.bridgebase.com/forums/public/style_emoticons/default/dry.gif

 

 

 

[maartenxq]

 

Partner had something close to Kx(x) ATxxx Kx(x) Axx and passed initially (I think it is quite clear to pass), but now jumped to 4H and wrapped up 11 tricks after guessing everything right incl. picking up the trumps that split J - Qxx.

 

 

I think your p has more reason to bid 3 ♥, than you have to dbl. She has a full opening and top controls. If you come in after this thinking and find such a hand I would for sure call td and hear your explanations with deep mistrust.

 

Maarten Baltussen