Would you interfere?

[heart76]

White vs Red, MPs.

Partner passes in 1st seat and RHO opens 1♦.

You hold: Kxx - 109xxx - K10xx - x.

Would you bid?

[Cyberyeti]

If I bid, 1♠ or 2♥ depending on how I was feeling, but probably pass.

[WesleyC]

I think pass is clear, but only because your suit is very poor.

 

If you improved the heart suit a little, say: [xxx KT9xx KTxx x] and you would get plenty of support for some level of interference.

[wank]

i have no objection to a style where you bid on much less than this, but only if your suit's sensible. here you have far too much defense relative to offense. 2H would be even worse.

[ggwhiz]

I overcall with this shape and point range all the time but only if I can at least stand partner leading the suit I bid so I pass here.

 

I WILL balance if they try to stop low as my partner can still have some flatish decent hands that others would open.

[Jinksy]

I will happily bid 2♥ here, but I've trained my partners (through bitter experience) not to lead my preempted suits in such positions unless they really have no better prospect, nor to raise it unless they really have the nuts for their initial pass. If partner is unlikely to bid again and I'm this weak, then ODR isn't that relevant - the opps very likely have game and possibly slam, and I want to make it harder for them to find which (and which one).

[wank]

I will happily bid 2♥ here, but I've trained my partners (through bitter experience) not to lead my preempted suits in such positions unless they really have no better prospect, nor to raise it unless they really have the nuts for their initial pass. If partner is unlikely to bid again and I'm this weak, then ODR isn't that relevant - the opps very likely have game and possibly slam, and I want to make it harder for them to find which (and which one).

 

this is a line i often hear but a 2 level wjo isn't very powerful though. its power comes from partner's raising it. you're losing the majority of the upside by playing such a loose method. you have absolutely no reason to think the opps have a slam on with ktxx of rho's suit and another king. partner's got 0-10 and it's more likely 10 than 0. in fact there's a fair chance they are due to go minus in game on this deal. of course if they happen to catch you in 2hx, it's guaranteed they'll be scoring more from it than whatever they can make themselves.

 

yes this kind of stuff works against clueless people though (at the cost of increasing variance) but i don't think there's much point answering on the forum with bad bids that might make clueless opponents make even worse bids.

[Phil]

I would overcall. This hand has nice positional values and could produce game opposite a weak NT. If partner had already passed I'd also pass.

 

Last night I held KQ Txxxx Kxxx xx but the opening bid was 1C, we were r/w and partner was a PH, so caution prevailed.