A Quick Poll

[PeterAlan]

IMPs (EBU club teams night).

 

[hv=pc=n&w=saj52ht3djt6ck984&d=e&v=n&b=2&a=p1cp1h1s2h(Alerted%3B%20shows%204%2B)3s4hpp]133|200[/hv]

 

You're W, a good club player. Natural Acol-style bidding; the alert of S's 2♥ was just because it promises 4; S could have 4 ♣s and 4 ♥s, but will then be 15+ HCP.

 

1. What calls do you consider?
    
   
2. Which call do you make?
   

(If you wouldn't have bid 3♠ on the previous round, please indicate.)

 

PS: The Alert was what happened at the table - it is not required by regulation. Please don't concern yourselves with it.

[eagles123]

1) pass

2) pass

[pran]

1) pass

2) pass

Agreed. West has completely told his story.

 

But that alert rule was funny (if it really is a regulation).

In my world South would have (support) doubled with 3 hearts (and passed with less) so he must have exactly 4 since he didn't open with a 1♥ bid.

[Vampyr]

Agreed. West has completely told his story.

 

But that alert rule was funny (if it really is a regulation).

In my world South would have (support) doubled with 3 hearts (and passed with less) so he must have exactly 4 since he didn't open with a 1♥ bid.

 

It seems to me that if support doubles are being played an alert here is sensible, though I don't know whether it is required by regulation.

 

I would consider and bid only pass, but not happily as I have badly misdescribed my hand with the 3♠ bid.

[billw55]

At these colors and in the passout seat, I will briefly consider 4♠ before passing.

[Cyberyeti]

It seems to me that if support doubles are being played an alert here is sensible, though I don't know whether it is required by regulation.

 

I would consider and bid only pass, but not happily as I have badly misdescribed my hand with the 3♠ bid.

 

What would you rather have bid opposite a passed hand 1♠ overcall ?

 

Also slightly relevant to this is what partner can't have (ie what a 2♠ opener would have shown, and how aggressively they open). I can't imagine bidding here, particularly if partner's pass wasn't in tempo.

 

Yes partner might have KQxxx, xxx, xx, Qx or similar and we might have a good save available, but once I've bid 3♠ I need to live with it, if I was going to bid 4♠ I did it last time.

[sanst]

What are the agreements on overcalls? It makes quite some difference if EW play weak jumps, in which case 1♠ shows a decent hand with values and double would certainly be an option, otherwise pass is a more than reasonable choice. But there might be players who would go to 4♠, given the vulnerability, especially when E has a habit of making very weak overcalls.

[nige1]

[hv=pc=n&w=saj52ht3djt6ck984&d=e&v=n&b=2&a=p1cp1h1s2h(Alerted%3B%20shows%204%2B)3s4hpp]133|200|

IMPs (EBU club teams night).

You're W, a good club player. Natural Acol-style bidding; the alert of S's 2♥ was just because it promises 4; S could have 4 ♣s and 4 ♥s, but will then be 15+ HCP.

1. What calls do you consider?
2. Which call do you make?

(If you wouldn't have bid 3♠ on the previous round, please indicate.)

PS: The Alert was what happened at the table - it is not required by regulation. Please don't concern yourselves with it.[/hv]

Peter, you might get a wider response, it you inserted a proper poll -- preferably one where you can see who voted for what.

 

On the previous round, you might prefer 2N to show a near maximum pass, with 4-card support, and some defence. (3♣ and 3♥ would have shown a 3-card raises, focusing on the better suit).

If you had previously described your hand, you would probably choose to pass, now.

Having previously misdescribed your hand, you might consider 4♠ too, now.

[gordontd]

I would consider and bid only pass, but not happily as I have badly misdescribed my hand with the 3♠ bid.

I don't think 3S is a mis-description opposite a passed-hand overcall, and I pass now.

[pgoddard]

 

1. What calls do you consider?
    
   
2. Which call do you make?
   

 

 

I consider but discard 4 Spades - I Pass.

[lamford]

I pass, only consider pass, and when I phoned a friend, Brother Anthony, he passed too.

[PeterAlan]

My thanks to all who contributed. This thread has completely fulfilled the purpose I had in mind when I posted the OP, and I'm very grateful to you all.