Transfer or Stayman?

[Vampyr]

But the issue was not whether 4♥ ought to be a splinter or whether it was a good idea to use it with a particular hand, assuming that it is a splinter. The issue was what 4♥ means in SAYC or maybe more to the point, how a partner who plays (or claims to play) SAYC is likely to interpret 4♥.

 

4♥ may well not have been assigned a meaning in SAYC, so I think that it is safest to assume partner will interpret it as the world does; as a splinter.

[InTime]

I think that the person asking is looking for a simple method having both majors. Fancy footwork is an agreement with your partner and there is nothing wrong with it. In the old days I have learned the following: 1NT - 2♣; 2♦ - 3♦ = both majors at least 5-5. This was sorta the standard even if you do not play transfers. If you want to get to 4M one can use Transfers, Smolen etc. and that is fine. However, if you want to make a further move with slam interest, these systems can create a problem for responder because he may have to set the suit providing him no space to advance with slam interest.

 

With the above you stay low and also provide the space for responder to advance further if he wants to after opener set the suit.

 

If you play 1NT - 2♥; 2♠ - 3♥ as at least 5-5 GF then you must have incorporated Smolen into your system otherwise it can be 5-4.

 

Also note that I am not playing this with my expert partner (we use the 3♦ bid for other methods). However, if you want to make it simple without much discussion and do have 3♦ available, this may be one of the simple ones.

Regards

[Vampyr]

I think that the person asking is looking for a simple method having both majors. Fancy footwork is an agreement with your partner and there is nothing wrong with it. In the old days I have learned the following: 1NT - 2♣; 2♦ - 3♦ = both majors at least 5-5. This was sorta the standard even if you do not play transfers.

 

Seriously? Where?

 

If you play 1NT - 2♥; 2♠ - 3♥ as at least 5-5 GF then you must have incorporated Smolen into your system otherwise it can be 5-4.

 

Or, er, reverse Smolen.

 

Also note that I am not playing this with my expert partner (we use the 3♦ bid for other methods). However, if you want to make it simple without much discussion and do have 3♦ available, this may be one of the simple ones.

 

Not as simple as just using 3♥/3♠ responses as 5+/5+ of different strengths -- provided transfers are being played. Or a 4♣ response (someone also suggested 4♦, which is fine if you are not playing Texas). All of these methods show the hand with one bid, and don't compromise the hands with hearts and diamonds, and are unusual enough that they will be noticed and therefore remembered by partner.

[helene_t]

In sayc there are no minor suit transfers for syrong hands and a direct 3m is nonforcing so 2c followed by 3d needs to be natural. It is the only way to show a strong hand with diamonds.

[Cyberyeti]

I think that the person asking is looking for a simple method having both majors. Fancy footwork is an agreement with your partner and there is nothing wrong with it. In the old days I have learned the following: 1NT - 2♣; 2♦ - 3♦ = both majors at least 5-5. This was sorta the standard even if you do not play transfers.

 

Seriously? Where?

 

I was brought up with extended stayman and stayman in doubt (one as 3♣ the other 3♦ not always the same way round) although haven't played either for years. In fact it was a very normal method precisely because you didn't play transfers then so couldn't transfer to one major and bid the other.

[JesseB]

Hello

 

Have always been confused with these hands. Playing SAYC, Partner at N opened 1NT and I had 6-6 Majors. Pls advise how best to bid. I play usual transfers but not Ogust. Thank you :rolleyes:

 

Kamal

[JesseB]

Hi, There are excellent SAYC lessons on BBO screen before you log on. They say: With less than invitational hand after partner's 1NT bid and 5/5 (can be as few as 3HCP, just transfer to your stronger major then pass. With invitational hand (8 or 9tp) transfer to hearts first then rebid 2S.

With game strength hand and 5/5 majors transfer to spades first then rebid your hearts. The strength of your hand is shown by which major you transfer to first.

[jerdonald]

BBO forum,

On the convention card under "NOTRUMP OPENING BIDS" we have:

 

3 clubs 5/5 minors weak

3 diamonds 5/5 minors game values

3 hearts 5/5 majors weak

3 spades 5/5 majors game values

 

This would also apply to 5/6 or 6/6 in majors.

With a 6 card minor we use a version of the "Four Suit Transfer".

 

Jerry D

[aguahombre]

In the old days,

1N-2H

2S-4H showed 5-6, longer hearts. For us, every day is an old day.

[helene_t]

BBO forum,

On the convention card under "NOTRUMP OPENING BIDS" we have:

 

3 clubs 5/5 minors weak

3 diamonds 5/5 minors game values

3 hearts 5/5 majors weak

3 spades 5/5 majors game values

 

This would also apply to 5/6 or 6/6 in majors.

With a 6 card minor we use a version of the "Four Suit Transfer".

 

Jerry D

Are you sure that is the sayc cc? Sounds more like bbo advanced

[Zelandakh]

3 spades 5/5 majors game values

Sounds just perfect for slam investigation - highly recommended.