Are you worth a move

[Winstonm]

What do you mean? It's of course less than %50, not even close. Just the club suit alone is %50 and you may not even have a guess at all. Then you have spade finesse off chances which is probably at least %15 due to overcall. Not done yet, you need 3-2 trumps.

 

I think even without discussion the jump to 4H in a reverse auction has to describe a strong, long suit that can play opposite a void: AKQ109x would be a minimum for that call, so we can easily assume AKJxxxx. An assumption can be made that the Spade king is with the overcaller, so that leaves clubs as the problem suit - if partner has the Q, voila'.

 

If this auction came up with any of my normal partners, I would be shocked if 6H weren't at least a 50/50 shot.

[the_clown]

I would pass. I dont think partner has a hopeless hand else he would have just bid 4♥ over1♣. But then again he knew that he was facing an unlimited hand and decided to make a double jump so he probably has his reasons. IMHO bidding now shows a lack of trust in partner.

 

Edit: Didnt see that 4♥ would not have been natural - now you have all the more reasons to pass.

[MrAce]

I think even without discussion the jump to 4H in a reverse auction has to describe a strong, long suit that can play opposite a void: AKQ109x would be a minimum for that call, so we can easily assume AKJxxxx. An assumption can be made that the Spade king is with the overcaller, so that leaves clubs as the problem suit - if partner has the Q, voila'.

 

If this auction came up with any of my normal partners, I would be shocked if 6H weren't at least a 50/50 shot.

 

The second I read your first sentence and the minimum suit quality required for this bid, I lost my interest about replying but I have to say that I disagree, completely.

[Cyberyeti]

The second I read your first sentence and the minimum suit quality required for this bid, I lost my interest about replying but I have to say that I disagree, completely.

 

The suit will be good and long, and the hand will have enough playing strength to be at the 4 level. It will not be ace empty to 7, it will have good intermediates unless very very long or strong. KJ10 8th or AK/KJ109/AJ109 7th would be the sort of holdings I'd expect when looking at the Q. The suit needs to be playable opposite a void for no more than 2 losers even on a less than totally friendly break.

 

Many people play a good/bad 2N over the reverse, I'm not sure what a "bad" 3♥ looks like if you play that, but some of the suggested hands are 2♥ rebids (or possibly 2♥ responses if you play WJS).

[whereagles]

Some people also play that all non-game bids after a reverse are forcing, e.g.

 

1♣ 1♠

2♥ 2♠ (5 spades, forcing, unlimited.. not your usual 5-8 HCP)

[MrAce]

Some people also play that all non-game bids after a reverse are forcing, e.g.

 

1♣ 1♠

2♥ 2♠ (5 spades, forcing, unlimited.. not your usual 5-8 HCP)

 

5-8 ? Usual? Where is that?

[Zelandakh]

5-8 ? Usual? Where is that?

Before learning Lebensohl or the like most learn that a minimum call is weakness and that GF hands start with the fourth suit. This is a horrible agreement and one reason why reverse auctions often end up being the toughest of all with a pick-up partner. As I have pointed out before 2♠ non-forcing is certainly playable though - you just have to build the rest of the structure to compensate.