Meaning of 5 hearts

[Wackojack]

[hv=d=e&v=n&b=2&a=pp1cd1n2hp5hp]133|100[/hv]

 

What is the meaning of the bid of 5♥

(a) the normal meaning

(b) your preferred meaning

[eagles123]

bid 6 with a club stop?

[lycier]

What is the meaning of the bid of 5♥

 

My answer ：

pd,are you second control in ♣?

1- If you have second control in ♣,you can bid 6♥.

2- If no,please pass.

3- If you have first control in ♣,you can cuebid 6♣.

 

 

 

 

[gszes]

agree with all other posters so far and feel it is such a nice simple and

perfectly understandable bid that there is no other preferred meaning needed.

how else to bid something like AKQJ AKxxxx void xx?

[Zelandakh]

It depends who your partner is! If playing with an expert partner then asking for a control in the opps' suit would be my expectation. If playing in the Acol Club with a pick-up it would almost certainly be a simple invite.

[silvr bull]

There is lots of space between 2♥ and 5♥, so partner can "ask" about a ♣ control by making strong que bids. I would treat the jump to 5♥ as asking about ♥s. I would expect North's jump to 5♥ to be a hand like AKQJx Jxxxx void AQJ. Granted that does not leave many high card points for the opps to bid, but that limitation does not seem to influence the BBO opps I play against. :D If I was South and I had ♥Axxx or ♥Kxxx, I would bid 6♥. If I had ♥AKxx, I would bid 7♥!