don't rebid 5 cd suit positive after 2c

[Stephen Tu]

[hv=sn=stephtu&s=SKJHKQJ97DA64CAKJ&wn=GIB W&w=ST862H54DKQT532C4&nn=GIB N&n=SAQ954HA832D9C863&en=GIB E&e=S73HT6DJ87CQT9752&d=n&v=n&b=21&a=PP2C(Strong two club -- 19+ HCP%3B 23+ total po)P2S(Positive -- 5+ S%3B 11- HCP%3B 6+ 8421 HCP in S%3B 8-12 total points%3B forcing)P2N(3- H%3B 2- S%3B 19+ HCP%3B 23+ total points)P3S(11- HCP%3B twice rebiddable S%3B 6+ 8421 HCP in S%3B 8-12 total points)P4S(3- H%3B 2 S%3B 19+ HCP%3B 23+ total points)P5H(Cue bid -- 1+ C%3B 1+ D%3B 11- HCP%3B twice rebiddable S%3B 7- 8421 HCP in C%3B 7- 8421 HCP in D%3B 8+ 8421 HCP in H%3B 6+ 8421 HCP in S%3B 10-12 total points%3B forcing)P6S(3- H%3B 2 S%3B 19+ HCP%3B 23+ total points)PPP]400|300[/hv]

 

- Why not 3h at its second turn? 3s should be 6+ spades IMO

 

- should west consider throwing in a 2d or 3d overcall at this vul?

[georgi]

Thanks for reporting.

 

Few tweaks for next v28.

 

3NT shouldn't be limited to 3 cards in other major. Book bid by responder was 3♥, but according to 3- limit for 2NT simulation probably neglected that call.

 

Anyway now it would be close to below meaning

2♣ - 2♥

2N - No support -- 2-4 ♣; 2-4 ♦; 1-2 ♥; 2-4 ♠; 22+ HCP; 23+ total points

 

Similar with 2♠ positive reply.

 

Book bid by responder also strengthen, so it won't miss to introduce 5+ 4+ shape and opener strong two could decide how to continue and in which suit. As for the displayed hand, 3H would come by responder 100%.