Jump to content

Your call? (Slam decision)


pclayton

Recommended Posts

[hv=d=e&v=n&s=skqxxhxdqtxcktxxx]133|100|Scoring: MP[/hv]

 

East.....South.....West.....North

1.......Pass.....2.......2

3.......4......Dbl.......Rdbl

Pass.....4.....Pass.....5

Pass.......?

 

1. 2 is preemptive

2. Rdbl promises 1st round control of 's

 

Your call?

 

Side note: what would you say the difference is between 4 and 4 - at round 2?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Clearly, pard has no club control. The problem is if he has

 

AJTxx

Axx

Axx

xx

 

or

 

AJTxx

Axx

AKx

xx

 

(or eventually a spade more and a diamond less) Since with the 1st hand he might have not made a slam try, I should play him for the 2nd. But in that case, what does opener have?? Did he open 1D on

 

x

Qxx

Jxxxx

AQJx

 

Unless opener is a maverick, I don't believe it. Someone is overbidding and my guess is pard is the one. I sign-off 5S.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You cue the suit you control, so 4 show contrrol

 

redouble shows first round contrrol

 

4 shows minimum

 

5 shows no control

 

There is no way I am gonna deny a control to an unlimited hadn after a negative, 6.

I'm with you, Fluffy !

 

After I showed minimum with 4, my partner insist towards slam only lacking control !

 

I have it so I bid it : 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites

At the table I tried 6.

 

It seemed I could put pard on either: Axxxxx, Ax, Axx, xx or more hopefully: Axxxxx, Axx, Ax, xx. 6 is ok on the first hand and fantastic on the 2nd.

 

Unfortunately, he held: Axxxx, A, Axxxx, Qx. I don't care for 5 much, diamonds are going to be overruffed in dummy, and thats if I have the hoped-for shortness.

 

We discussed the 4 / 4 cue. With this pard; 4 is the heavier bid; it probably shows an offshape max that couldn't compete over 1. 4 shows the hand I had.

 

With my other pard, we decided that the cue shows the control in the red suit with no reference to strength.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It seemed I could put pard on either: Axxxxx, Ax, Axx, xx or more hopefully: Axxxxx, Axx, Ax, xx. 6 is ok on the first hand and fantastic on the 2nd.

Am I seeing this right?

 

KQxx.....Axxxxx

x...........Ax

QTx.......Axx

KTxxx....xx

 

is hopeless unless clubs are 3-3. And

 

KQxx.....Axxxxx

x...........Axx

QTx.......Ax

KTxxx....xx

 

requires trumps 2-2, no? Far from fantastic, I think.

 

Unfortunately, he held: Axxxx, A, Axxxx, Qx. I don't care for 5 much, diamonds are going to be overruffed in dummy, and thats if I have the hoped-for shortness.

This confirmed my impression pard was overbidding :blink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It seemed I could put pard on either: Axxxxx, Ax, Axx, xx or more hopefully: Axxxxx, Axx, Ax, xx. 6 is ok on the first hand and fantastic on the 2nd.

Am I seeing this right?

 

KQxx.....Axxxxx

x...........Ax

QTx.......Axx

KTxxx....xx

 

is hopeless unless clubs are 3-3. And

 

KQxx.....Axxxxx

x...........Axx

QTx.......Ax

KTxxx....xx

 

requires trumps 2-2, no? Far from fantastic, I think.

 

Unfortunately, he held: Axxxx, A, Axxxx, Qx. I don't care for 5 much, diamonds are going to be overruffed in dummy, and thats if I have the hoped-for shortness.

This confirmed my impression pard was overbidding :P

Your right on the 1st; require clubs 3-3. On the 2nd; we have 10 trump; so it only requires 4-2 clubs and 2-1 spades and the A onside. Virtually cold on this auction, I'd say.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am curious to know what a 5 heart bid would mean overall at this point. I would interpret it as indicating a heart control, and it should imply a club control. Otherwise, why ask P for something that he/she already implied not having (assuming 5D denied a club control). Do I have more, the same, or less than I showed by bidding 4H? Does P's 5D bid improve or worsen my hand. My diamond cards don't appear to be much given the diamond bid on my right, but a heart control might be the information P needs to bid or not bid 6. I hope the rewind of 4HX shows 1st round control. Key cards alone apparently aren't partner's concern- had another bid for that. lol I never get these situations right.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...