Jump to content

Comments?


the hog

Recommended Posts

Much as I like Moscito and find it a highly aggressive system, there is no doubt it is liable to pre emption.

 

As a matter of interest I am posting the opening bids of a new system that has many of the advantages of Moscito, but tries to take are of the pre emption problem. Your comments are invited.

 

1C

11-14 balanced, including all 4432 4333 5332

OR 14-17 any single or 2 suiter

OR 18+ any

 

1D

10-14 4+H, unbalanced, may be canape

 

1H

10-14 4+S unbalanced, may be canape in a minor

 

1S

10-14 4+D unbalanced

 

1N

15-17

 

2C

10-14 6+C

Or

4+4+ Majors, 0-10 depending on vul of course

 

Full relays over all openings

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't like the "OR 14-17 any single or 2 suiter" part of 1. These hands need a somewhat more precise first move (and so do the weak notrumps and the strong hands).

Wouldn't like the six-card 2 on grounds of frequency if there weren't a second hypothesis.

 

Would prefer something like

 

1 11-14 balanced or 17+

1 10-14 unbalanced with 4+ hearts

1 10-14 unbalanced with 4+ spades

1 10-14 unbalanced with 4+ diamonds

1N 15-16, no void, no second five-card suit (and perhaps no six-card suit as well)

2 10-14 with 6 clubs or weak with 4+ spades and 4+ hearts

2 14-16 with diamonds (6, 5/5 with clubs or 5440 with clubs) or weak with 6 hearts or 5 spades and a 5-card minor

2 14-16 with hearts (6, 5/5m or 5=0=4=4) or weak with 6 spades

2 14-16 with spades (6, 5/5m or 0=5=4=4) or weak with 5 hearts and 5 clubs

2N 14-16 with both majors (5/5 or 5440 - even 5m -) or weak with 6 clubs

3 14-16 with 6 clubs or weak with 5 hearts and 5 diamonds

 

After 1N 2, 2 is balanced and relays back, and the other bids show a shortness, which admittedly wrongsides 3N on occasion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ron -

 

1) Hiding 11-14 5M332s in the 1C bid is going to be a loser, IMO. Are you doing this to accomodate the relays?

 

2) While 1C will not be as inviting to interference as a 15+ strong club, it seems to me that it will be more vulnerable to actual instances of interference than a pure strong club. What are your schemes for handling 1C-2H and 1C-P-(your negative response)-2H, for example?

 

3) I suggest a name - "Polish Moscito" :lol:

 

Peter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In 1 word? YUK! ;)

 

Against:

1. I'm still not convinced that it's a good idea to open 1NT with 5(M)332 hands. Your own successful preemptive possibilities are not efficient anymore I'm afraid.

2. Seems like you have to open 1 with 5432 - 2 - 32 - AKQJT2 since the 2 opening probably only contains the singlesuited hands. Wonderfull if partner supports with 876 in s and a void .

3. I don't like the 37 way 1 opening since these are also quite vulnerable to preemption. Perhaps if you'd give the response scheme, I might become convinced :lol: .

 

Pro:

1. I like the idea of opening weak 44+M hands, and with the 2 opening you mix the natural opening with the weak possibility. Only sacrifice is point 2 from above.

2. Seems like the relayschemes after 1 and 1 openings will be quite efficient. Also the singlesuited relayscheme of the 2 opening can now start from 2 instead of 2NT.

 

Remark: What do you open with 15-17 and a 3-suiter? There's no opening for that...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"Remark: What do you open with 15-17 and a 3-suiter? There's no opening for that"

 

Yes there is - open 1D/H

 

Interestingly this system was played succesfully in Istanbul.

Success of a pair playing a system is not always a merit of the system,

we can conclude that 2/1 is either great or horrible depending on who play the system and the same for the rest of the systems.

What you really need is a chemistry between the players and the system for every pair there's one system that will suit them better to maximize their results.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...