Double or 6?

[Hanoi5]

Mp's, you're red, they're white:

 

♠A

♥xx

♦Jxxxx

♣AQTxx

 

2♥-X-4♥-5♣

5♥-???

 

I know double is not correct, but let's say it just came out of the bidding box before you could notice it. Do you double, pass or bid 6♣?

[32519]

Interesting question, but where are all the ♠?

 

Partner bid 5♣ voluntarily over 4♥ so he must surely have some values (probably a ♥ void as well). Both sides appear to have a huge trump fit and shortage in the opponent’s suit, probably intending to cross-ruff the hand out. The ♦ suit is just too anaemic to risk 6♣. If partners HCP is something like ♣KJ and ♠KQJ you still have a potential problem with the ♦ suit. I would pass.

 

At MPs, any plus score is obviously better than a minus score.

[gszes]

the original "eccentric" x has paid off lets not waste it

your hand is a ton more interesting than if you had a

normal tox but it is also somewhat weaker. An x here

warns p that you do not have a desire to bid higher and

that is what I suggest. If west had passed over 5c would

you have 6c??? probably not and the 5h bid should not

change that decision it merely gives you another bid to

help limit your hand when it comes back to p. At these

colors x is weaker than pass.

[han]

The title is as insane as doubling 2H.

[daveharty]

At MPs, any plus score is obviously better than a minus score.

 

I believe this is true at all forms of scoring.

[rmnka447]

You can't know if 6 ♣ has any play at all. Also, you really can't be sure who is saving and who is sacrificing. So pass the decision back to partner by passing.