Overcalling their Jacoby transfer

[Bbradley62]

I liked my 3♥ bid, but GIB chose to double with the North hand. What are GIB's criteria for differentiating between the two bids?

http://tinyurl.com/7uoqc8r

http://tinyurl.com/8329aqc

[pigpenz]

I prefer your call cause it puts more pressure on the opponents

x should be more a hand where you show that suit and likely hood of playing in another

cue bid should be 3 suit take out

 

too many times playing with GIB you can really bid your suit over 1NT and what it does is it

leaves a transfer or way of opps showing their suits at a lower level, thats why GIBs crappelletti system

is so unworkable.

[pigpenz]

when did this result happen , did a search in my hands for both you and kibbeh and couldnt find the hand

i was curious about the results I would imagine 4♥-1 would be avg plus plus

[Bbradley62]

It happened this morning in MBC, but I left the table before this hand had been played 16 times in my scoring group (it had been played 15 times) so the hand didn't make it to myhands. Yes, most tables were EW 3S= for 140, so I gained a little.

[pigpenz]

It happened this morning in MBC, but I left the table before this hand had been played 16 times in my scoring group (it had been played 15 times) so the hand didn't make it to myhands. Yes, most tables were EW 3S= for 140, so I gained a little.

Ok, thanks was curious about the result

but def like your 3♥ call better than the double