1X-1Y-(2Z)-2NT = weak or strong?

[Grizz1y]

I too often see players bidding like:

 

1C - (PASS) - 1S - (2D or 2H)

2NT

 

with only 13-14 hcp.

 

In my book, 2NT in this sequence clearly shows 18-19 hcp, since responder has only shown 6+hcp.

And with 12-14hcp balanced, you should pass after interference at the 2-level, if you dont have any other bid.

 

But is it normal in std system to bid 2NT above with only 13-14 hcp?

[Trinidad]

Hi!

 

Welcome to the forums.

 

You are 100% correct 2NT shows 18-19. If you have a minimum balanced hand, you just pass (unless you can raise partner, of course).

 

Rik

[Vampyr]

This depends on your NT range. When playing weak NT, you might play that 2NT is 15-17 (or 15-19). It is more common to double here with a strong NT, but that has some problems too, for instance that partner doesn't know whether you have a strong NT or a more classic TO shape.

[SimonFa]

With my old partner we played that 2NT with flat 12-14 was mandatory IF we had a stopper in ops bid suit.

 

Yes it might mean playing 1NT with 18HCP but it seemed to pay off more often than not, especially at MPs. With 18/19 its time for a thin 3NT.

 

I wouldn't do it without prior agreement though.

[helene_t]

This depends on your NT range. When playing weak NT, you might play that 2NT is 15-17 (or 15-19). It is more common to double here with a strong NT, but that has some problems too, for instance that partner doesn't know whether you have a strong NT or a more classic TO shape.

15-19 is unplayable since partner has not shown values for game opposite 15. What is he supposed to do with 7-8 points opposite a 2NT rebid showing 15-19?

 

But if 2NT without the interference would be 18-19 (in a weak NT system) it makes some sense to play it as 17-18 here. With 15-16, just pass. Or double, if your hand fits whatever criteria you have for a double in this position.

[barmar]

With my old partner we played that 2NT with flat 12-14 was mandatory IF we had a stopper in ops bid suit.

 

Yes it might mean playing 1NT with 18HCP but it seemed to pay off more often than not, especially at MPs. With 18/19 its time for a thin 3NT.

ITYM "playing 2NT with 18HCP".

 

Why not just wait for partner to reopen? If you have enough for 2NT he'll balance; if he's minimum he'll pass and you don't get too high.

[SimonFa]

ITYM "playing 2NT with 18HCP".

 

Why not just wait for partner to reopen? If you have enough for 2NT he'll balance; if he's minimum he'll pass and you don't get too high.

 

Not sure about the method, I'd just started playing and he supplied some system notes that said it was mandatory to bid NT at the lowest available level with 12-14 after opening. Obviously not too high.

 

I don't play it now as he has moved on, but it seemed to work, although we got caught a couple of times.

[awm]

Some professional bridge teachers in the LA area were bidding/teaching this 2N bid on 12-14. They got very upset when I suggested it should be 18-19.

[aguahombre]

Some professional bridge teachers in the LA area were bidding/teaching this 2N bid on 12-14. They got very upset when I suggested it should be 18-19.

This seems to be more of a reflection on the quality of professional bridge teachers in the L.A. area. Oh, for the ones of old (50's to 70's) in the same region.

[SimonFa]

This seems to be more of a reflection on the quality of professional bridge teachers in the L.A. area. Oh, for the ones of old (50's to 70's) in the same region.

 

To be clear, we only bid NT at the 2-level if the 1-level had been taken away.

[MrAce]

To be clear, we only bid NT at the 2-level if the 1-level had been taken away.

 

Just because 1 level is taken away doesnt give you free pass to bid NT at 2 level.

 

And this question OP asked is NOT a matter of style either.

 

1♦--1 whatever = 5+ hcp (some do it with much weaker hands as well)

 

now this is pure and simple bridge logic, why on earth one would want to bid 2NT with 13 or 14 hcp vs his pd's 5 hcp ? To show that he has 13 hcp incase pd didnt see we open ?

 

You dont have to be a bridge theorician or einstein to figure 2NT with 13-14 is ridicilious.

 

This is not like making a preempt, 2 NT is very easy to DBL contract. You have a balanced hand and no fit to run. Even if u run and find a fit it will be at 3 level probably balanced vs balanced. Once one of them make a 2/1 overcall with 11-12 other will easily dbl 2NT with his 10+. And once u guys are doubled at 2 NT u are in probably auto DBL path.

 

Congrats, you just expressed your hand perfectly by bidding 2 NT. Pd already knew u had 13 hcp and now you told him u have an honor in their suit too, ending in playing 2NT doubled or 3 something doubled for a 4-3 or 4-4 fit if u are lucky. Even worse, now that u play this 2 NT 13-14, u have to jump to 3NT with 18-19 hcp hands, totally preempting your side when u guys actually have the ongoing values.

[wank]

To be clear, we only bid NT at the 2-level if the 1-level had been taken away.

 

as others have pointed out, bidding 2NT on these auctions with 12-14 is totally wrong, not just a question of style. it happens to be very common among weak players who don't understand bidding theory though.