takeout X or Neg X

[123600]

Bidding was Pass,1♣,X, 1♠ X

Is the second X a takeout or Neg X

[BunnyGo]

Shows spades generally. If not, the opponents will psych a 1 spade bid here.

 

If I were forced to pick between your two choices, then my answer would be:

 

I don't understand the functional difference between it being takeout or negative. They seem the same to me.

[ArtK78]

A takeout double is a negative double (and vice versa).

 

A penalty double is a positive double (a term one rarely encounters in the bridge literature but it does exist).

[sasioc]

X here should show 4 spades and a 2S bid shows 5 spades. As the other responders have mentioned, a negative double is the same thing as a takeout double (and this is not one, although it is not exactly a penalty double either).

[wyman]

X here should show 4 spades and a 2S bid shows 5 spades. As the other responders have mentioned, a negative double is the same thing as a takeout double (and this is not one, although it is not exactly a penalty double either).

 

I would X with 5 rags and bid 2S with a more robust spade holding, but yeah same idea.

[neilkaz]

I would X with 5 rags and bid 2S with a more robust spade holding, but yeah same idea.

 

Same

[sasioc]

I would X with 5 rags and bid 2S with a more robust spade holding, but yeah same idea.

 

 

Sure, I didn't mean that *every* hand with 5 spades should bid 2 spades, just that the 2 spade bid showed 5.

[Free]

Dbl is usually played as penalty oriented, showing ♠s, because many players psych 1♠ in such auctions (read: the frequency of this being a psych is much higher than average). This guards against clowns. ;)

[mck4711]

penalty. 4+ cards in ♠ and 6+ HCP

[ggwhiz]

I hate stolen bids in general but this double is the only one that I play.