Jump to content

splinter or bid game, or something else?


  

24 members have voted

  1. 1. you bid?



Recommended Posts

I assume 2 is minimum opening values for you.

 

You are off 5 keycards AK AKQ, and also A and or K might substitute cards in clubs. This means that slam is possible althou unlikelly.

 

I'd try splinter, better if 3 is splinter, leaves you more room. I expect to end up in 5 80% of the time at least.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I assume 2 is minimum opening values for you....

......I'd try splinter, better if 3 is splinter, leaves you more room. I expect to end up in 5 80% of the time at least.

 

Indeed 3 should be a splinter, cannot imagine it being anything else.

 

Thats the bid I would make, and I'm passing 3NT.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

i presume 4 is in there as a joke.

 

i don't want to play game if i can avoid it. obviously i don't want to play slam.

 

i'll try 3 - that should be enough to buy it as the opps seem to have skipped the lessons on overcalls

 

Have you misread the problem? You don't want to play game cannot be right.

I will bid 3H. I am sorely tempted to bid 5D though as I expect 3H will incur a x and some competition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if splintering might influence them to sacrifice, even though they haven't entered. Partner's support implicates he doesn't have much on the side (AKQJ3 are missing and partner has 4 of them, what else can s/he have?). I think 5 is enough, I'll just punt to that.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

i presume 4 is in there as a joke.

 

i don't want to play game if i can avoid it. obviously i don't want to play slam.

 

i'll try 3 - that should be enough to buy it as the opps seem to have skipped the lessons on overcalls

I do want to play game, slam can be good (x, xxx, AQJx, AQ10xx) but is unlikely. I don't want to splinter as opps clearly have a massive double fit in the majors and it might wake them up, so I will bid 5.

 

If partner has K, KJx, KQJx, xxxxx I'm taking a small bath, but I can't believe either opp can double for penalties, and at most tables opps may well be playing a making part score or game in the majors.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if splintering might influence them to sacrifice, even though they haven't entered. Partner's support implicates he doesn't have much on the side (AKQJ3 are missing and partner has 4 of them, what else can s/he have?). I think 5 is enough, I'll just punt to that.

 

 

I do want to play game, slam can be good (x, xxx, AQJx, AQ10xx) but is unlikely. I don't want to splinter as opps clearly have a massive double fit in the majors and it might wake them up, so I will bid 5.

 

If partner has K, KJx, KQJx, xxxxx I'm taking a small bath, but I can't believe either opp can double for penalties, and at most tables opps may well be playing a making part score or game in the majors.

I agree with this

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am very surprised to see things like "I do not want to play slam". This raise is 100% 4 card support, and that is my 8 card suit (I checked twice). I can only assume partner holds at least 5C or they would have opened 1D. I have no idea what happened to the majors on this deal and why the opps are not entering the bidding holding 20 (count em TWENTY) major suit cards with both suits. The great news is I am 50 %, or more, for no major suit losers, I can at most have 1 trump loser, and (bless his soul)partner has opened where I have 3 small.

 

Now I have found that there are many players who hold 4D that look like AKQJ and 5 C Kxxxx would open the bidding 1D.They may even have AQxxx in C. I consulted with the crystal ball which remained cloudy. Could it be possible I could fake a splinter in partners suit? Are you sure? OK, as this is a once in a life time hand that is never coming my way again EVER, and because partners have NEVER raised my 8 card suit in the first round of bidding, I take a mild chance and land myself in 6D.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am having hard time to figure what the heck is going on, pd opened 1 and raised , that makes our side has 11 or 12 and at least a side 8 card fit. I am looking at a void and 6 hcp in my hand when pd said he is minimum. And opponents are not bidding. LOL. That must be a dream! :D
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am having hard time to figure what the heck is going on, pd opened 1 and raised , that makes our side has 11 or 12 and at least a side 8 card fit. I am looking at a void and 6 hcp in my hand when pd said he is minimum. And opponents are not bidding. LOL. That must be a dream! :D

 

Some people play that the 2 bid shows reverse values (I don't) but I would still call 911 and check the opps for a pulse.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would just bid 5. Partner has at least 6HCP in and a minimum opening hand. I don't think we can make slam, but game is likely.

 

Btw, why don't you use bots in PB? You get them for free in the flash version, and they don't do crazy stuff. ;) Much better to learn how to bid imo, since it's more realistic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd say even 3 has no chance.

East has

AKQxx

x

Axxx

xxx

which is an awkward hand to have when someone opens clubs.

 

North has

KJ

KQJ (x)

KJx (x)

xxxx

 

Of course East has a shoddy quality

Michael's hand

 

 

 

Just bid 3 not because it makes but because it makes it even more awkward for opponents to choose what to bid.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...