Jump to content

2D/other defense


straube

Recommended Posts

I've played leaping Michaels for a long time, but I always wondered what the full thing was. Also how to defend against a weak 2D. Found this and inviting comments (like is this how most people play?)

 

2D (3D) majors

2D (4C) hearts and clubs

2D (4D) spades and clubs

2D (4N) blackwood

 

2H (4N) minors

2H (4H) minors, bigger

2H (3H) running minor, asks for stop

2H (3S) invitational spades

 

3S (4S) hearts and a minor

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 years later...

I've played leaping Michaels for a long time, but I always wondered what the full thing was. Also how to defend against a weak 2D. Found this and inviting comments (like is this how most people play?)

 

2D (3D) majors

2D (4C) hearts and clubs

2D (4D) spades and clubs

2D (4N) blackwood

 

2H (4N) minors

2H (4H) minors, bigger

2H (3H) running minor, asks for stop

2H (3S) invitational spades

 

3S (4S) hearts and a minor

What about the rest of your defense to a 2 preempt i.e.

Double = takeout of

2NT = Natural, balanced, HCP range according to partnership agreement

New suit = Natural (is this forcing or non-forcing according to partnership agreement?)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've played leaping Michaels for a long time, but I always wondered what the full thing was. Also how to defend against a weak 2D. Found this and inviting comments (like is this how most people play?)

 

2D (3D) majors

2D (4C) hearts and clubs

2D (4D) spades and clubs

2D (4N) blackwood

 

I looked up Michaels cuebid again. These guys say use Michaels with a weak hand (5-10 HCP) or a strong hand (16+ HCP). With an intermediate hand (11-15 HCP) bid the higher ranking suit first. I put these numbers through BBOs deal generator to get an idea of the frequency of occurrence. This is what was spat out:

0.45% = 5-10 HCP

0.33% = 11-15 HCP

0.08% = 16+ HCP

0.86% = Overall frequency of occurrence

 

I don't like this suggestion of yours here. I prefer this -

2D (3D) majors (this is fine, no problem; use it for the weak Michaels hand i.e 5-10 HCP)

2D (4C) hearts and clubs I prefer plus an unspecified major. To ask for the unspecified major, responder bids 4. The reason I choose this is because your next suggestion below forces the auction to 5 when partner has preference for but an otherwise bust hand. Following my suggestion allows partner to pass 4 with preference for and an otherwise bust hand, and to ask for the major with preference for the majors

2D (4D) spades and clubs I prefer this to show the strong Michaels hand i.e. 16+ HCP

2D (4N) blackwood [blackwood with no suit agreed upon? Can you please give some more detail as to what you have in mind here?]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2D (4C) hearts and clubs I prefer plus an unspecified major. To ask for the unspecified major, responder bids 4. The reason I choose this is because your next suggestion below forces the auction to 5 when partner has preference for but an otherwise bust hand. Following my suggestion allows partner to pass 4 with preference for and an otherwise bust hand, and to ask for the major with preference for the majors

This can be extended further as follows -

1. With slam interest in either major, bid 4 to ask for the major

2. With no slam interest, bid 4 as P/C

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This can be extended further as follows -

1. With slam interest in either major, bid 4 to ask for the major

2. With no slam interest, bid 4 as P/C

 

That just doesn't work. What does the advancer bid with a poor 4144 hand? I'd sure like to play 4S when it's right. That's why people suggest having 2 bids to show clubs and a major.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel pretty strongly that over 2D you should have 2 bids for the majors. There is a big difference in a hand that wants to overcall and is 5-5 majors (3D), and a hand that actually wants to force it to game, and obviously both majors is an important hand type. In fact I even prefer to play 2H (3H) michaels and 2H (4m) leaping michaels but that is more controversial and few people agree with me on that :P
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That just doesn't work. What does the advancer bid with a poor 4144 hand? I'd sure like to play 4S when it's right. That's why people suggest having 2 bids to show clubs and a major.

Ever notice you have a 9-card fit?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...