Bid Game at MP ?

[hanp]

I don't know if unbalanced is more likely, maybe it's 50-50 on the relevant hands. Either way, Dirk was clearly off when he said can that really be the deal? . Of course it can.

[gwnn]

Well I don't know either which is more likely, singleton or no singleton, if we eliminate the hands that would force to game anyway.

 

However, I am pretty sure that two out of three hands with 4333 shapes (partly dismissing the third one) is not a fair sample.

 

Do you agree with this hanp, or do you have some other minor qualm?

[Fluffy]

4333 10 counts are simple raises, even with A-K-K. We opened in third position.

[hanp]

However, I am pretty sure that two out of three hands with 4333 shapes (partly dismissing the third one) is not a fair sample.

 

Do you agree with this hanp, or do you have some other minor qualm?

I think you had ample opportunity to read that I wrote "Dirk was clearly off" 18 minutes earlier gwnn.

[Fluffy]

listen to gwnn, he offers you common sense

agree with myself ;)

[gwnn]

However, I am pretty sure that two out of three hands with 4333 shapes (partly dismissing the third one) is not a fair sample.

 

Do you agree with this hanp, or do you have some other minor qualm?

I think you had ample opportunity to read that I wrote "Dirk was clearly off" 18 minutes earlier gwnn.

I read that hanp but you used that to preface an out of context quote ;)

[jdonn]

Oh no, 2 of my 3 favorite posters at each other's throats!

[gnasher]

Do you agree with this hanp, or do you have some other minor qualm?

Don't you mean a minor quibble?

[gnasher]

Do you agree with this hanp, or do you have some other minor qualm?

Don't you mean a minor quibble?

Or, in fact, simply a "quibble", since a quibble is by definition minor.

[jdonn]

But a qualm isn't, so now you are quibbling with yourself.