Follow-up after 1D-2C in precision sys

[flytoox]

Suppose you play pretty standard precision, i.e., 1C=16+,1N=13-15.

 

What is best (or better) follow-up structure after 1D-2C? Do you rebid 2N with any minimum balanced hand. If you rebid 2M, does it promise shape or extra HCP or just 4D+4M?

[rbforster]

How light are your 1D openings, and how sound is 1D-2N?

[flytoox]

How light are your 1D openings, and how sound is 1D-2N?

I personally prefer 1D shows good 11, with either shape or quality cards, say

 

AXXX,XXX,AKXX,XX, I would open with 1D happily. However, I hate opening with KJXX, QXX, KQXX,XX.

 

1D-2N is invitational, showing 11-12.

 

In my sys, 1D-2C is abosolutely FG.

[bluecalm]

One more important thing is what do you do with GF hands with 4M - 5m.

It's kinda easier to plan subsequent auction if you reply 1M with those.

[flytoox]

One more important thing is what do you do with GF hands with 4M - 5m.

It's kinda easier to plan subsequent auction if you reply 1M with those.

I never do that. I hate it:) and I always bid minor first if I have a good hand and 5m4M.

[bluecalm]

Meckwell and Greco-Hampson use artificial structure (2♥ is 11-13bal, 2♠ is 4card support + shortness) etc. My feeling is that their choice was dictated by playing not forcing to game 2♣ and 2♦ (thus having 3♣/3♦ bid for weaker hands) because they need a way to bid with both invitational and GF hands and 2♠ relay after 2♥ response allows for that. I also feel that in their system you really should bid 1♥/1♠ with 5♣-4M and less than slam invitational hands.

If those are forcing to game in your system I think you can get away with much simpler solution (and not having those "ugly" canape in your structure)

 

I would go with this basic scheme:

 

2♦ = 5+diamonds

2♥/2♠ = natural 4+, without 5♦

2NT = balanced without 4card major

3♣ = minimum but 4card ♣ support unbal

3♥/3♠ splinters with ♣ support (4+)

 

Now in sequence:

 

1♦ - 2♣

2♦ - 2♥/2♠ are 3rd suit may be values, may be 4card suit (partner bid 3NT with both 4card support and stopper in 4th suit; raise to 3 without stopper)

 

If you have game forcing hand with clubs and don't have natural 3rd suit to bid you just bid 3♣ (this is a problem if you don't play 2♣ as GF).

 

1♦ - 2♣

2NT - here I feel you may want to use 3♦/3♥/3♠ as shortness with 6♣;

 

You have two free bids 3♦ and 3NT.

You may want to assign 4-4-4-1 max hand to 3NT and 2-2-4-5 hand to 3♦ for example.