email discussion.

[mike777]

1h=1nt

2c=2h

 

1) In your 2/1 style what is the minimum and maximum 2h can be?

2) How few clubs could 2c be?

3) What would 3c rather than 2h be for you?

4) What would 2s rather than 2h mean for you?

[jjbrr]

1. minimum=0, maximum = 10ish

2. 3

3. constructive

4. good club raise

[Jlall]

2. 3

flanneryyyyyyy

 

Haha, seriously I don't understand question 2, it just depends on your system. How about "0, I play gazilli."

[jjbrr]

2. 3

flanneryyyyyyy

 

Haha, seriously I don't understand question 2, it just depends on your system. How about "0, I play gazilli."

His first question says "In your 2/1 style" so presumably he wants to know what your system is.

 

Ya. 2♣ could be 2 with 4522 and weak hearts. I forgot that one.

[jdonn]

2. 3

flanneryyyyyyy

 

Haha, seriously I don't understand question 2, it just depends on your system. How about "0, I play gazilli."

His first question says "In your 2/1 style" so presumably he wants to know what your system is.

 

Ya. 2♣ could be 2 with 4522 and weak hearts. I forgot that one.

And weak hearts? You rebid 2♥ with 5 strong hearts?

[jjbrr]

Sure. Is that terrible?

[jdonn]

I think it's bad, and it's definitely weird, 2♣ on 4522 is the normal rebid. What's the point if 2♣ can still be a doubleton anyway so you aren't even fixing a problem?

[Little Kid]

1) 0 up to to anything less than direct 2♥ raise with 3+♥, or any hand too weak to invite giving false preference.

2) 2

3) ~8-9 and 5+♣, interested in game opposite extras.

4) Stronger ♣ raise than 3♣.

[P_Marlowe]

#1 10HCP - but in this case it would be an extreme misfit, say 5-5,

a 5422 hand would be sold to p as bal. 10-12

#2 3

#3 constructive raise, weaker than

#4 best raise, lets say hans with a strength from 10-12, most likely more

HCP based strength

[hanp]

I play gazilli, 2C does not promise clubs, 2H shows 0-7 points, 2S shows both minors, weak, and 3C shows clubs, weak.

[Jlall]

I play gazilli, 2C does not promise clubs, 2H shows 0-7 points, 2S shows both minors, weak, and 3C shows clubs, weak.

Stole my joke :(

[hanp]

Nope, yours is still up there.

 

I however, do play gazilli.

[Codo]

1. 3-7 HCPS with 3 hearts or 3-10 with 2.

2. 3

3. 4+ clubs natural but weaker then 2 ♠, so about 6-8 HCPS

4. 4+ clubs, good raise, 9-11

[Free]

2. 3

flanneryyyyyyy

 

Haha, seriously I don't understand question 2, it just depends on your system. How about "0, I play gazilli."

If you play Kaplan inversion, you also have 3+♣ for a 2♣ rebid... :blink:

 

I like kaplan inversion AND gazzilli, so that's 2 jokes in 1 :D

[Fluffy]

I think it's bad, and it's definitely weird, 2♣ on 4522 is the normal rebid. What's the point if 2♣ can still be a doubleton anyway so you aren't even fixing a problem?

There are worse things to do :blink:, it depends on how often you pass 2♣, I have the impression that I pass 2♣ much more than most of the forum crew.