What the &*%# is going on here?

[mtvesuvius]

How do you interpret this auction? LOL

 

1♥ - 3♣ - P - P

3♦ - 3♠ - P - 4♠

5♦ - P - 5♥ - 5♠

P - P - 6♥ - 6♠

X - All Pass

 

Wth is going on here? Can you construct any hands that fit this auction?

 

(Result at the time was -1)

[manudude03]

Let's think of it one hand at a time.

 

Dealer: Most likely some extreme red suiter (say 1660, 12-7-7-13 remaining)

 

2nd seat: Some extreme and weak black suiter (say 5017, 7-7-6-6 remaining)

 

3rd seat: Probably a fairly weak hand with club length and doesnt want to bid hearts first due to fear of getting taken for 500 (say 2425, 5-3-4-1 remaining)

 

4th seat: Hand has most of the points in spades, can't see much defence to 6♥ and was initially walking the dog (5341)

 

This makes me think of a hand such as:

 

[hv=d=n&v=n&n=sxhakjxxxdaktxxxc&w=sakqxxhtxxdjxxxca&e=sjtxxxhdxcjtxxxxx&s=sxxhqxxxdqxckq98x]399|300|[/hv]

 

I'm not saying the bidding would be correct, but seems like the most sane construction I can think of.

[helene_t]

Something like Wayne(Manudude)'s example, but I South's bidding seems inconsistent. He passes over 3♠ and then bids hearts twice voluntarily later.

[wclass___]

Maybe E-W had agreed that they play michales 3♣=5♣+5♠+ NF as suggested in Revision club.

And West forgot the meaning, but after 3♠ remembered...

[ArtK78]

If I held

 

x

AKJxxx

AKTxxx

---

 

I wouldn't rebid 3♦ at my second turn to bid - I would rebid 4♦ - maybe 5♦. Even 6♦ is not unreasonable. So the North hand cannot be this strong or this distributional - one or the other.

 

This hand is a favorite for 12 tricks opposite xxx xxxx xxxx xx.

[hanp]

This hand is a favorite for 12 tricks opposite xxx xxxx xxxx xx.

Don't play me for the perfect 0-count partner, I never have it.

 

(I completely agree with your point of course)

[manudude03]

I realise what you are saying about the N hand being way too strong for 3D(honestly, I agree), but I can't think of a single hand which has just got better when its become more likely partner is nearly broke, which makes me think he just underbid (quite severely) the first time.

 

I also admit that south's actions are pretty strange (the passing 3S part anyway). The "voluntary" heart bids might not be so voluntary though, 5H would be a simple preference, then read N's pass of 5S as forcing and so bid 6H with no defence.

 

ps. I wouldn't pass 3D with xxx xxxx xxxx xx.