More ATB

[mtvesuvius]

[hv=d=s&v=n&n=sakqt9hadt854ckj6&s=s7hkq6543dk2ct753]133|200|Scoring: MP

Playing Precision, South Deals:

 

2♥ - (3♦) - 3♠ - (Pass)

4♣ - (Pass) - 4♠ - (X)

Pass - (Pass) - 5♣ - (X) - All Pass

 

Once again I got to declare this wonder... I guess down 2 is not good bridge.[/hv]

[JLOL]

South should bid 3N after 3S.

 

North should bid 4H after 4C.

 

North should not bid over 4S X.

 

North's bidding was awful, I'd say 85 %.

[P_Marlowe]

Hi,

 

#1 I think I like the suggested 3NT instead of 4C.

#2 I am pretty sure, that I dont like 4C, for me this

would implicitly agree spades, being a cue.

#3 I dont understand 5C, a typical panic bid, partner

passed 4Sx, why dont I?

 

I guess 5C is a lot worse than 4C, so most blame goes

to North, but usually the guy who causes the mess, is the

one, who started it, which was South with the 4C bid.

 

With kind regards

Marlowe

[jdonn]

I think north should crack 3♦. I thought that before seeing south's hand with it's singleton spade and Kx of diamonds, and admit it could work out badly but I think it's odds on. It's not like he would be giving up a sure game anyway, it could easily be the case that bidding gets his side too high.

[JLOL]

I think north should crack 3♦.

True, didnt even notice that.

[whereagles]

I guess down 2 is not good bridge.

You're right. It's better bridge :)