Handle 3S

[pclayton]

[hv=d=w&v=n&n=sa853hkj6dt63ca72&s=skt72haq2dq852c83]133|200|Scoring: MP

p - p - p - 1D;

1H - dbl - 2C - 2S; P - 3S - AP[/hv]

 

MPs, weak game. LHO leads the club 9, you duck, K.

 

RHO continues a low club, 8, 10, A.

 

Any creative ideas here?

[mikeh]

I have to admit that I began by not understanding this auction... it sure looks like a weak field, in all 4 seats.

 

let's see: I passed a 12 count in 2nd seat, with 5 controls, two 10s and no rebid issue. Who am I? Roth or Stone?

 

Then I opened 1♦, reasonably enough, with a modest 11 in 4th seat, but felt obliged, with a flat hand and the same 11 I started with, to bid 2♠ rather than wait to see if partner could bid... knowing that he almost certainly could, since (unless everyone at the table passes opening hands) he has about 9-11 hcp. Maybe I didn't notice that my 11 count should be devalued because the heart K is probably offside?

 

Then, as North, having heard partner open and then voluntarily bid 2♠, and having an opening hand that I have hidden so far, upgradable to a sound opening due to the heart position (most opps will have a heart honour for this overcall) I invite game???

 

Frankly, playing with either partner, I lose interest rapidly. Why bother thinking about declarer play when neither partner knows anything about bidding?

 

Sorry if this seems insulting, Phil... altho I suspect that you may not have been either N or S :)

[pclayton]

I have to admit that I began by not understanding this auction... it sure looks like a weak field, in all 4 seats.

 

let's see: I passed a 12 count in 2nd seat, with 5 controls, two 10s and no rebid issue. Who am I? Roth or Stone?

 

Then I opened 1♦, reasonably enough, with a modest 11 in 4th seat, but felt obliged, with a flat hand and the same 11 I started with, to bid 2♠ rather than wait to see if partner could bid... knowing that he almost certainly could, since (unless everyone at the table passes opening hands) he has about 9-11 hcp. Maybe I didn't notice that my 11 count should be devalued because the heart K is probably offside?

 

Then, as North, having heard partner open and then voluntarily bid 2♠, and having an opening hand that I have hidden so far, upgradable to a sound opening due to the heart position (most opps will have a heart honour for this overcall) I invite game???

 

Frankly, playing with either partner, I lose interest rapidly. Why bother thinking about declarer play when neither partner knows anything about bidding?

 

Sorry if this seems insulting, Phil... altho I suspect that you may not have been either N or S :)

No Mike I played it and I could not count on my pard to reopen - or I could have been playing 3♦ for all I know.

 

I know this isn't real bridge (it isn't to me anyway), but I really didn't post the hand to elicit an editorial, sorry.

 

Perhaps its easier if you just pretend partner did open open 1♣ and we ended up in 3♠ after I invited :)

[Codo]

I would play two round of spades, 3 round of hearts and play a 3. spade hoping that West will win and take his diamonds because he does not like to play in the double chicane. I play him for Qxx,xxxxx,AKx,Qx and some defensive errors. :)

[cherdano]

I would play two round of spades, 3 round of hearts and play a 3. spade hoping that West will win and take his diamonds because he does not like to play in the double chicane. I play him for Qxx,xxxxx,AKx,Qx and some defensive errors. :)

LHO led ♣9 and followed with ♣T.