Jump to content

What has our partner...?


Poky

Partner's 2S bid should be...  

13 members have voted

  1. 1. Partner's 2S bid should be...

    • Non-forcing (some specific sign-off hand)
      2
    • Non-forcing (but invitational)
      6
    • Forcing (invitational or better)
      5
    • Forcing (game forcing)
      0


Recommended Posts

Before deciding what this bidding shows, you have to answer these question. Would a double of 2 by opener show 3s (support double)? I will assume that it in fact would have for my answer. Second question is what would a balancing 2NT (instead of a double) here show? Is this natural with a stopper (not a good use of this bid imho), or lebehnshol? These have important implications on removing hand types from the meanin of the dbl followed by 2. For instance, a strong game invite hand in would go like this for me.... 1-(1)-1-(2)-P-(P)-2NT-(p)-3-(p)-3 *NF invite. An immediate jump to 3 would have been GF.

 

The availability of the 2NT followed by 3 bid and the availability of 2NT to bail out in when weak with a fit, allows double here to be the flexible bid. That is, when you are not so sure what to do next. First, the double should be short in in case partner has a penalty double of 2 (since I play immediate dbl of 2 as either support dbl or takeout -- depending upon partner I am playing with). When your partner doesn't pass 2 dbl, the 2 bid should be non-forcing but invitational. It is invintational because you could have always simply bid 2 over 2 if that is what you wanted to do. The implication is that the 2 bidder has a lot of (good five or six+) and a tolerance for (doubled 2 and pulled , so must be willing to have withstood a 3 bid). Opener can bid 3 when holding weak hand and singleton .

 

Ben

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would a double of 2 by opener show 3s (support double)?

 

No. It would be simply a negative double, showing extra values and shape, but often holding 3.

 

Second question is what would a balancing 2NT (instead of a double) here show?

 

A natural ~11 balanced invitation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is a very difficult problem, because I should see my own hand before I can say what partner has. It depends on my length to know if my partner's initial Dbl was optional or not. And since I can't know that at this moment, there's no way to continue.

 

His Dbl was either optional (short s) or now GF... Can't give an accurate answer due to not enough information.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

-----------------------------------------------------------

Hi Poky!

 

------

My answer will be based on your agreements. Why your p dbl? Because he is short in and you can be trap pass , despite their fit. What about his strength? He have about 8-11hcp, suitable for defense - this mean deny good suit or sure fit(5+cards). Because lack of 4 cards in , he have (3)4 cards in . Using same sequences as rf/gf is bad practice in competition, when you have free 3 cue bid for same hands, because complicate nature of such bidding and avoiding stupid mistakes.

 

------

Hi Ben! Balancing position is one of most difficulte and usage of 2NT as convention will help a lot, as well as anywhere at 2 level of competition. If you like to bid 2NT you can simple dbl first and bid it later, if your p didn't pass of course :huh: .

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------

Misho

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...