bidding problem

[eamongall]

The following hand occured at our recent national team championship's and I wonder if you would be good enough to ask the bidding panelists their views on what they might bid.

 

N/S Vul

N Dealer

 

N E S W

1H 4S P ?

 

You as West hold

 

S T98

H void

D AQJ32

C AJT76

 

 

 

Do you bid on? And if so, what do you bid?

 

thanks

Eamon Galligan

[Free]

Pass for me

[Apollo81]

A competent LHO rates to bid 5♥ if I pass, so I will bid 5♠ now and hope he doubles instead. People tend to always think you are sacrificing if you bid like this at favorable.

 

I think the odds heavily favor 5♠ making and are slightly against 6♠ making.

[skjaeran]

A competent LHO rates to bid 5♥ if I pass, so I will bid 5♠ now and hope he doubles instead. People tend to always think you are sacrificing if you bid like this at favorable.

 

I think the odds heavily favor 5♠ making and are slightly against 6♠ making.

Either a tactical 5♠ or 5♥ - a strong raise.

Depending on who I'm playing with and against.

[Guest Jlall]

I'll cut partner some slack here since he's white/red. I see no reason to think LHO is going to bid 5H. He's red/white and doesn't have much (since I have everything).

[bid_em_up]

I think the odds heavily favor 5♠ making and are slightly against 6♠ making.

I think 5♠ rates to be cold, and 6♠ is heavily favored.

 

My heart void, and the lack of a 5H bid by RHO tends to indicate that partner has three or 4 hearts along with his 6-8 spades. This doesnt leave him with many minor suit cards, and any minor suit losers go away on the diamonds after a non-club lead.

 

If I just bid 6S directly, the odds are against RHO finding the club lead, but if I try cuebidding 5H (to show the control/void) or 5D to show the suit, I think I improve their chances to find the club lead.

 

I'll bid 6♠ and pray that we don't have two trump losers. Who knows, they may even decide to sac in 7H. :)

[pclayton]

I'll pass. AKQxxxxx, xxx, x, x is just too much to wish for. KQJxxxx, xxx, xx, x is more the norm at these colors.

 

We might have some handling problems if dummy gets tapped at T1, and pard doesn't have solid spades.

 

If LHO tries 5♥, I'll take the push to 5♠.

[whereagles]

My first feeling was to bid 6, so that's what I do ^^

[P_Marlowe]

pass, ...

 

With kind regards

Marlowe

[jdonn]

I guess 5♥ is fine, I don't like the 'tactical' 5♠ since like Justin says they are so weak they won't be doing anything anyway, and 6 is clearly an overbid.

[Fluffy]

5♣ for me, I might try for 7 if partner cues.