YUK -1

[sceptic]

here goes I bid 3H

 

[hv=d=e&v=n&n=st876ht9dkqj8742c&w=sqj4hak2dt965cak3&e=skhqj874da3c76542&s=sa9532h653dcqjt98]399|300|Scoring: IMP[/hv]

 

West North East South

 

 -     -     Pass  Pass

 1NT   3♦    3♥    Pass

 Pass  Pass  

 

 

what should I do?

[fred]

Bid 3H just like you did. This is forcing in "standard" (not that I have ever read this in a book on "standard" but I have never heard of any strong players using 3H here as a signoff - which is apparently how your partner read it).

 

It should be noted that if 1NT is weak (clearly it wasn't here) and if the responder is a passed hand (as he was here), it makes a lot more sense for 3H to be non-forcing.

 

Here is a nice (non-standard!) convention that you can use in this situation. I mentioned this the other day as a vugraph commentator and the audience (and other commentators) seemed to like this idea (as they should!).

 

When partner opens 1NT and they overcall 3D:

 

3H=invitational or better with 5+ spades

3S=forcing to game with 5+ hearts

 

When partner opens 1NT and they overcall 3C you can do even better:

 

3D=invitational or better with 5+ hearts

3H=invitational or better with 5+ spades

3S=forcing to game with 5+ diamonds

 

This is one of those rare conventions in which the advantages so clearly outweigh the disadvantages that I am not even going to bother explaining why this is the case :)

 

But this is not the sort of convention you want to use except in a serious partnership - too easy to forget it otherwise.

 

Fred Gitelman

Bridge Base Inc.

www.bridgebase.com