who should do what?

[sceptic]

[hv=d=e&v=e&n=s5h982dkjt9cak863&w=s83hjt65da654cq97&e=skqt7642h4dq8732c&s=saj9hakq73dcjt542]399|300|Scoring: IMP[/hv]

 

West North East South

 

 -     -     3♠    Pass

 Pass  Pass  

 

 

me sitting over preempter

 

1/. what should I do

 

2/. what should p do?

 

thanks

[mr1303]

1. Bid 4H. It could be disasterous, but that would be unlucky. It might be completely the wrong thing to do, but that's why we pre-empt.

 

2. Possibly double, but probably pass. You need partner to have a lot to make something, and without 4 hearts it could be messy.

[hotShot]

Well the preempt worked, you are now unable to fully describe your hand.

 

I would bid 3NT now. You hold 2 tricks in ♠, 4-5 in ♥ and since RHO (should be short) and you are short in ♦, partner will hold a ♦ stop (I hope). If i get dbled i can still try to run to one of my 5 card suits.

You should not dbl because you can bet partner will bid ♦, so the 2nd best shot is bidding ♣ or ♥. ♣ is the better choice for trumps as the ♥ will make tricks anyway.

 

If you pass, your partner is to weak to try anything. Any hand bidding over a preempt should be very solid.

[temp3600]

Over such a preempt, I play cautious direct action and aggressive reopenings, so :

 

1. Pass

2. clear X

[Echognome]

Personally I think the 5530 hand is good enough to act. I would bid 4♣ if playing non-leaping Michaels over 3-level preempts and double otherwise. If partner bids 3♦, I bid 3♥ and hope he figures it out. It is going to be tough without much in way of agreements. I think one either needs to play non-leaping michael's or equal level conversion here. You have so much space eaten up that the need to double and bid a single-suiter is lessened. It can easily go (3♠) - X - (4♠) - P - (P) - ? And now you are going to have to introduce your own suit at the 5-level without much knowledge from partner.

[mr1303]

3D/H are unfortunately insufficient. Maybe you could try 4H over 4D though....