Who is to blame?

[Fluffy]

The balme goes to south for reopening with such junky trash many times before, now he pays for it :)

[Kalvan14]

I prefer a 3N reopener. There are plenty of (weaker) hands in N with which 3N is a lay-down or almost so.

This said, double is a reasonable alternative, with a fit in all the unbid suits. N bid (4♦) is a bit shy: his 10 HCP are all working: I would have bid 4N for the minors, but I am not so convinced that i would bid 6♣.

Which goes to prove that, overall, 3N is the best bid at MP.

[han]

The balme goes to south for reopening with such junky trash many times before, now he pays for it :D

This is a regular but fairly new partnership so you are mistaken.

 

Also, I am not one of the two players, I received this hand by email.

 

 

BTW 6C goes down on a 4-1 break. I wonder how good 6C is given the spade preempt.

[cherdano]

BTW 6C goes down on a 4-1 break. I wonder how good 6C is given the spade preempt.

57.77%.

 

Not a good bet if the other table is in 4♦..

[Fluffy]

The balme goes to south for reopening with such junky trash many times before, now he pays for it <_<

This is a regular but fairly new partnership so you are mistaken.

 

Also, I am not one of the two players, I received this hand by email.

 

 

BTW 6C goes down on a 4-1 break. I wonder how good 6C is given the spade preempt.

The fact the partership is new doesn't mean he doesn't know the kind of reopenings he sues to make lol.

[Fluffy]

Now more seriously, the problem here is lack of agreements, strenght for direct move and reopening is a very important one for a partnership.