Misinformation, wrong explaination = Yes. Damage... well - I am not sure Pairs E/W wulnerable. Dealer South. South - West - North are advanced+ East is Expert. N/S is a regular parthership. E/W are not. South - West - North - East 2c 2S 3D(1) 4S 5C pass 5D(2) Pass(3) Pass(4) Double Pass Pass 5H(5) Pass Pass(6) Double All pass 11 tricks made. 750 NS 95% score to N/S 10 KQ9432 987654 --- West ---East KJ653 ---AQ982 75 ---86 KJ3 ---AQ2 A105 ---743 74 AJ10 10 KQJ9862 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 2C = precision 1) = Transfer to Hearts. Explained as non forcing bid of diamonds. 2) = I have diamonds also. 3) = Partner. your decision. 5spades or double. 4) = Agreed heasitation. 5) = South remembers now about the transfer. But gives no explaination. 6) = North thinks the auction is over and explains that he has Hearts and Diamonds. TD is called at the end of the auction. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- a) East will always bid 4♠, not matter about the MI. b) In case of (3). Would east pass as forcing with right explainaton ? if having the correct meaning? Not sure, but likely. b2) And if West had known about ♥and ♦, would have doubled the 5♦ bid ? = Yes likely c) In case of (5). Would west have bid 5♠ with correct explaination ? - I do not think so. E/W wanted to play in 5♦ undoubled. 9 tricks. 90% score to E/W Well - My ruling was... no damage. Table Score stands. Perhaps I am totally wrong. When there are so many quiestions with no clear answers, I should have adjusted score to 40/60, or tried to find some weighted score. Greetings from Iceland Vigfus Palsson