With an overcall hand of 12pts or more I prefer to bid 1 diamond, even if short, if my right hand opponent is the dealer and opens 1 club and I have no 5 card major. My card is marked for expected minimum length of 3 for 1 diamond. My regular partner (wife) and I normally play best minor. My partner and I have a standing agreement to pass the other's minor opening if they do not have sufficient points (6-9) for a response. The above has happened twice in the past 6 months - both times we ended up with top boards and both times the director was called and the play allowed. Both times my partner did not know what I was doing and refuses to accept this oddity in bidding. Both times my explaination to the director was that it was a psych bid. Were the directors correct? :) When does a psych bid turn into an alertable bid? :huh: Since my partner refuses to accept this oddity and annouce the bid as "possibly could be as few as 0" can I announce it prior to play since I know my partner will not announce it during play? Thank you for you comments.