christyw

There was a review which upheld the TDs decision. The accusation of lying was made by a player at the table.

As a TD at the event ( National League Division 1) I agreed with the table TD who accepted Souths statement "I do not play checkback over 2N" and the card as evidence and Norths statement "I made a mistake" One may not like the methods stated but one should not verbally accuse a fellow player of lying. I also happen to know of another W who failed to return his partners spade.

Dealer W E produces a stop card he is told it's not your turn and the TD is called The TD establishes Easts intention was to make a jump bid thinking he was dealer Is it correct to rule this under Law 31 B as a bid out of rotation?