This is the full hand [hv=d=n&v=n&n=s4hakqj98dk72caq3&w=sk106h76dj8654cj87&e=saj9752h102daqc954&s=sq83h543d1093ck1062]399|300|Scoring: IMP[/hv] As told before North moved from 3Nt to 4♥. After director's rule (4♥ stands) the team appealed, claiming that South has passed unauthorized information to North and the showed availability of contracts (I have hearts but I am sure that it's ok), and claiming for adjustment to 3NT - 4 (♦ lead and ♠ shift - 6♠ and 2♦ = 8 tricks for the defense). The defense is automatic, and nothing extraordinary. The appeal commitee rejected the appeal. The point is that North has every right to bid anyhing he wants, especially 4♥ with a sing BUT after the long pause he has no right to do so. I would accept the bid after the pause, with 7321, 6421, 7330, 6430 and so, patterns that usually don't belong to NT. Am I wrong? After all North showed his hand, its partners desicion now. I think that both director's and appeal's commitee decisions were wrong because they examined the bid by North not having in mind the long pause and the availability of contracts that South offered. Fil