I think an important point is that 2♠, in the original post, is a playable spot. It is possible to construct a sequence where player 1 has made a non-forcing bid, player 2's following bid does not show any extra strength or lenght (typically, a preference), and player 1's next bid is natural, but cannot be a playable spot, and therefore has to be forcing 1 round : 1♥ 1NT 2♣ 2♥ 2♠ Spades are at most 3-3, so responder cannot pass 2♠. So I would say that if player 1 has made a non-forcing bid, player 2 makes a bid that does not convey anything extra, and player 1's next bid is a playable spot, then it is non-forcing. If it is not a playable spot, it is forcing 1 round.